This an absolutely terrible option. It's rife with abuse, and even when fair, is only right slightly more than it's wrong. It doesn't resolve any of the underlying issues, which continue to exist. It seems to be better than any of the other last-ditch options, but it's incredibly bad.
Even among your allies, you're still stuck with the same problem. Being allies you're hoping that their core agreements with you will enable tactics like steelmanning to work, though in a lot of cases it still doesn't.
How can we approach this problem?
To take your example of the abortion issue in America, your steel man argument has to explain why an acorn is the same as an oak tree, or perhaps the difference between an acorn and a fertilized human egg. They have to account for the mass murder of fertility clinics and researchers throwing out thousands of fertilized embryos per day.
Or you could choose to accept their philosophical argument about the start of life as a given, and discuss the consequences of it. E.g. you have a right to kill another human in self defence, unless the person threatening your life is inside a womb. Or the conditions under which you have a right to another person's life and body. Is there an innocence test we could do for organ transplant recipients, where the top end of the scale gives you a right?
Lots of room for good faith discussion there, even on immaterial subjects.