Your world view is contradictory.
Is success mostly luck? Or is it mostly skill?
You repeatedly state that it's mostly luck. A poker tournament.
At the same time you believe some marketers are better than others and want to hire the good ones.
So it must be mostly skill. But you said business success is luck. Hire random people as marketers, random people as programmers. It doesn't matter if they have skill since it's all luck anyway.