Sure it’s possible that social media will never improve, but that’s unlikely. We’ll collectively figure it out
Sure it’s possible that social media will never improve, but that’s unlikely. We’ll collectively figure it out
I grew up way before the internet. Children on my Highschool were really mean. Many, many bullies were around. Pretty girls talking bad about less pretty girls. And much more.
The big difference: we now see it on a different scale and start talking more about it. But the people haven’t changed.
Maybe a bad example is nuclear technology. It can be good or bad, but we recognize that the downside is just too big to allow unfettered access to it.
This echoes nature vs nurture in psychology and can be debated interminably because the truth is it's not just one or the other, it's both
We need to acknowledge the powerful ways our tools influence our behavior, just as we need to recognize and reclaim our own agency in using them. Both these perspectives must coexist if we are to form mature relationships with our technology
Yes people have always been mean. Doesn't mean social media isn't a large amount of gasoline on what used to be a pretty small and localized fire.
Used to be in the open (circa LiveJournal/Tumblr) but everything started moving to closed Instagram circles and the like, particularly messaging apps that allow senders to retract messages or alter any easily-discoverable paper trail. Kids are moving away from SMS and onto Snapchat/Whatsapp for spin control.
So bullies become "victims" when they provoke someone, receive a predictable response, then delete the provocative messages they sent (which is deleted on both ends!). The resulting conversation makes it look like the victim is attacking the bully.
The bully claims harassment by victim to parents and teachers. Neither subpoenas for records so they accept the bully's story and evidence and punish the real victim.
They didn't. The television networks did control all television news, but newspapers were thriving. Indeed, local newspapers were thriving.
Which raises the related question: how many do we need? For a while our assumption was "the more the better," but as it turns out there seems to be a limited number of good journalists in the world, and making them compete with an infinite number of bad ones has resulted in a race to the bottom.
Social media as a concept is fine. The business model behind all social media is toxic.