MIT, BSD, and GPL 2.0 also do not surrender those rights. They just don't helpfully remind the licensee of this fact in the body of the license itself. The net result is, so far as I can tell, the same.
It would seem to me that the complaint is with a license which doesn't surrender rights, particularly patent rights. I think this is proper: MIT, BSD, and GPL 2.0 are awful licenses for exactly this reason.
*Edit* A quick mention of MIT. There are people who argue that MIT's "without restriction" clause sort of acts as a patent release. As if that was good. MIT is a bad license because a critical feature of a modern license -- a patent release -- hinges on a strained interpretation of a vague, easily misconstrued statement, and one which was clearly not the intention of the original license authors. A good license would have explicitly spelled things out. It takes just one judge to grind the MIT license into dirt.
> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software
It doesn't say anything about copyright or patents. It merely provides a list of things that I am allowed to do. To decide that they haven't granted all rights required to use the software would seem to contradict what was written in the license.
> No trademark or patent rights held by Affirmer are waived, abandoned, surrendered, licensed or otherwise affected by this document.
and a license with no clause at all addressing trademark or patent rights? Wouldn't both of those documents leave trademark and patent rights unaffected?
> The MIT License unquestionably has an express [patent] license. That license is not limited to the granting of any particular flavor of intellectual property rights. The statement of license does not use the word "patent" or the word "copyright." When was the last time you heard someone expressing concern that the MIT License merely had an implied copyright license?
CC0 is a public domain dedication, with fallback license for jurisdictions where public domain dedication is not possible. The public domain dedication part is not a license (this was a large part of the legal criticism of the awfully-named Unlicense: that it tried to be both a public domain dedication and a license, despite the two being incompatible), and so cannot do anything with trademark or patent rights.
If you want to cover trademark or patent rights, you’ll have to use a public-domain-equivalent license instead of a public domain dedication. This is where things like 0BSD come in. (With this latest thing, I think I’m going to change my primary recommendation in https://chrismorgan.info/blog/unlicense/ to 0BSD rather than CC0.)