If instead the real reason is Fedora wants all licenses to include explicit "patent licensing or patent forbearance", that's different than the rationale excerpted by LWN here.
If instead the real reason is Fedora wants all licenses to include explicit "patent licensing or patent forbearance", that's different than the rationale excerpted by LWN here.
In a situation like this where the license explicitly says "this is not a waiver of any patent rights" that argument is going to be pretty hard to make fly.
The whole area is interesting for sure. The very presence of explicit patent grants/waivers/forbearance in later licenses could be argued as evidence that a waiver isn't commonly understood to automatically come with the license where it's totally silent. But that's still a different world from the "definitely not a waiver" situation set up by CC0.
This feels incompatible with a spontaneous patent claim, because otherwise "use" is not permitted once a patent right is asserted.
The notion of open source is under threat from patents being used by the likes of Facebook, who've released BSD code then immediately claimed a special patent license in a parallel that disavowed "redistribution and use" unless the patent license also applied.
So we can say that a license that explicitly doesn't include patent permission doesn't meet the 4 freedoms.
> The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose.
A patent overrides this.
> The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish.
A patent overrides this, at least the second half.
> The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor.
A patent overrides this.
> The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others.
A patent overrides this.
Facebook's React library was an example of this. BSD but with a non-free patent license that ran against those freedoms. So it was not really open source.
If the patent holder puts a "redistribution and use are permitted", that can be deemed as an IP license in every relevant way, including patent and trademark grant; it's not just copyright.
"Use" means carrying out the patented functionality; permission to "use" is tantamount to permission to apply the patented algorithm to one's data to reap its benefit.
Perhaps the Creative Commons lawyers erred by mentioning patents at all, and they should issue a corrected “CC0v2”!
Whereas with CC0 it's explicit that the same person who granted you the code could sue you for running it. There's no room for interpretation.
But it does do exactly that.
> It just makes clear that CC0 is silent on those issues
It doesn't do that, because that's impossible to do. Saying "I'm not talking about X" is talking about X.
Someone can absolutely say “Though some might think my prior words endorse or reject X, let me be clear I don’t endorse or reject X.” You can mention X, especially in a aspires-to-be-rigorous context like law, without committing to a treatment.
Yes, it does.
A license that gives permission to use software but does not enumerate specific rights that the licensor holds which may be necessary to use the software will most naturally be read as licensing all necessary rights held by the licensor.
A license which explicitly disclaims any grant of patent rights can only be read as...not granting patent rights held by the licensor, even if they may be necessary to use the software. Thus, such a grant which would otherwise be reasonably included is, instead, explicitly precluded.
Yes, and this seems to be the entire reason that Fedora is revoking approval of the license.
"The reason for the change: Over a long period of time a consensus has been building in FOSS that licenses that EXPLICITLY DISCLAIM PATENT FORBEARANCE cannot be considered FOSS."
...I'd have not flagged any apparent textual contradiction – and understood the rationale better. It was the broad, unqualified allegation that CC0's text would "preclude any form of patent licensing or patent forbearance" that created the impression of mismatch between reasoning and literal text.
(And note: submission link has changed since I commented from a tiny excerpt of Fontana's announcement, and the full email.)
I dont think it is. I really dont see how you could read that sentence and get "i reject x" out if it.
More specificly its saying "the previous statement i just made is not me saying i am giving you a patent license. However i'm not saying in general whether or not i am going to give you one, and i might be giving you one in some other statement."
There is of course a certain sense where not rendering an opinion is the same as the supporting the status quo ante (which would be no patent license), but i dont think its fair to equate an implicit no opinion = no patent license with an explicit no patent license.