While the majority of people might still redeem the code themselves, you can't automatically assume that the person who bought it is the one using it.
While the majority of people might still redeem the code themselves, you can't automatically assume that the person who bought it is the one using it.
...and even if you think you can convince a jury, it's still enough to issue a search warrant, whereby the prosecutor will find more than enough charges to force you into a plea deal.
Your initial anonymity is your most important defense.
What exactly do you base this on?
First of all, Mullvad (like any serious VPN operator) do not log IP:s and one can probably safely assume they do not log who bought which gift card. They are also under no obligation to do so, as far as I’m aware.
But let’s assume for the sake of argument that they did: let’s assume they log IP:s and sales of gift cards down to the social security number of the person who bought it.
Now assume that I’m running a corner store where I sell among other things these gift cards, that I bought from Amazon at a small markup.
Someone uses these gift cards and the tracking (that doesn’t exist) leads back to my store.
I’m defending myself in court in a democratic western country where people are assumed innocent until proven otherwise.
The jury (in the US) or the judge (anywhere else) is informed that I buy these cards in bulk, I sell dozens of them a week, and the IP (that Mullvad doesn’t log) is a dead end.
Do you seriously believe that a judge or jury anywhere would sentence me for the crime brought forward, or that this would even hold water enough to be prosecuted in the first place?
This is almost exactly analogous to selling anonymous SIM cards (where they still exist). One is used for a drug deal. Me, the shop keeper, is prosecuted in this alternate universe because I’m selling the cards.
Really?
There are no such countries; that standard would make it impossible to get convictions for almost every crime that ever occurred.
Compare this case from the United States: https://volokh.com/2014/01/02/wrongful-convictions-proof-bey...
> In October of 2007, Elizabeth P. Coast, then seventeen, reported that when she was ten years old a neighborhood boy named “Jon” sexually assaulted her while the two were alone in her grandmother’s backyard
> [the trial court] tried and convicted Montgomery in a one-day bench trial for the assault of Coast. Coast testified under oath that Montgomery had sexually assaulted her in 2000.
> no other witnesses to the incident testified at Montgomery’s trial. Neither was any corroborating physical evidence that an assault occurred ever presented. The trial judge categorized this case as a “word against word situation.” In reaching his verdict, the trial judge concluded that Coast was more credible then Montgomery because she had “no motive whatsoever” to lie. The trial court then found Montgomery guilty of forcible sodomy, aggravated sexual battery, and object sexual penetration. On April 10, 2009, the trial judge sentenced Montgomery to 45 years in prison, with 37 years and 6 months suspended…
> On November 1, 2012, Coast voluntarily made a videotaped statement at the Hampton Police Department. After consulting with counsel and receiving Miranda warnings, Coast recounted how she had falsely testified that Montgomery had assaulted her.
> Coast explained that immediately before she accused Montgomery, her mother caught her looking at “sex stories” on the Internet. Out of fear of her mother, Coast said that she was looking at inappropriate material because she had been molested when she was ten years old. After she reluctantly named Montgomery as her attacker, the lie snowballed. Coast felt like she could not admit that the assault never happened
Generally speaking, "innocent until proven guilty" is a cornerstone in most legal systems. This has been the case, literally, for millennia, dating back to Roman times.
It is also one of the UN's human rights, and is enshrined in several countries' constitutions.
You could publish a dozen similar anecdotes every day for a decade. What's unusual about this one is that the girl was stupid enough to later admit she'd been lying.
> Generally speaking, "innocent until proven guilty" is a cornerstone in most legal systems. This has been the case, literally, for millennia, dating back to Roman times.
> It is also one of the UN's human rights, and is enshrined in several countries' constitutions.
So? Compare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Constitution_of_the_Sovie...:
> The Soviet Constitution included a series of civil and political rights. Among these were the rights to freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and freedom of assembly and the right to religious belief and worship. In addition, the Constitution provided for freedom of artistic work, protection of the family, inviolability of the person and home, and the right to privacy. In line with the Marxist-Leninist ideology of the government, the Constitution also granted social and economic rights not provided by constitutions in some capitalist countries. Among these were the rights to work, rest and leisure, health protection, care in old age and sickness, housing, education, and cultural benefits.
Of course, having the rights in the constitution didn't mean anyone was allowed to exercise those rights, and they most certainly weren't. "Innocent until proven guilty" is a set of words that people believe in saying, but it is not a set of beliefs that people are willing to put into practice. It has nothing to do with the legal system of any country in the world. For most crimes, proof of guilt cannot even theoretically exist. (As was true of Elizabeth Coast.)
This was covered fairly extensively in my first link:
> What’s doing the work in many of the convictions, I suspect, is that the very ubiquity of the risk makes factfinders realize that — if we were to constantly consider this generalized risk, in the absence of more specific information — a wide range of crimes couldn’t be effectively prosecuted. That’s especially true of child molestation and rape, but it’s also true of many sorts of felons’ possession of guns, robberies, and the like. It’s always possible, and not extremely unlikely, that a police officer was just trying to frame someone he already thought was a bad guy.
> But I think many people (again, deliberately or subconsciously) are unwilling to see acquittals in all such cases. A seemingly disinterested supposed victim’s testimony thus tends to be credited (unless the victim seems untrustworthy for other reasons, such as the victim’s own past criminal record). A police officer’s testimony tends to be credited, at least by many jurors. And this is so even though there is good reason for doubt, simply because whenever we are dealing with human testimony there is good reason for doubt.
> So... the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard ends up being, in many cases, considerably less defendant-protective than one might think. Maybe that’s bad, or maybe it’s a necessary evil
So? Once again, they are anecdotes. I can similarly provide thousands of anecdotes showing presumption of innocence. It means nothing except that those cases happened.
Do you have any proof "it is not a set of beliefs that people are willing to put into practice" on a systematic scale?
> So? Once again, they are anecdotes.
"Anecdote" doesn't just mean "something I'd prefer not to have to think about", you know. Being very common makes the event systematic.
> Do you have any proof "it is not a set of beliefs that people are willing to put into practice" on a systematic scale?
Yes, we've been talking about it for a while.
> I can similarly provide thousands of anecdotes showing presumption of innocence. It means nothing except that those cases happened.
That's... not how logic works. On the one hand, we have hundreds of thousands of cases of people being railroaded for crimes they didn't commit based on no solid evidence. On the other hand, we have tens of millions of cases of people being railroaded for crimes they did commit, also based on no solid evidence.
But let's assume that second group consists only of convictions where the defendant's guilt was somehow actually proved. That wouldn't mean the system operates on the principle that people are innocent until proven guilty -- that claim is already falsified by the existence of the first group. It would mean that proof of guilt is often provided even though it isn't required.
The thing is that when dealing with something on the scale of the justice system even a hundred examples don't mean it occurs more than a fraction of a percent of the time. When assessing anecdotes to try and determine event frequency you need to understand how the anecdotes were sampled.
The law and law enforcement are two different things. Law enforcement works roughly like this: they get an IP of a website, they go to an ISP, the ISP says its this reseller, they go to the reseller, the reseller says it is this customer, they go to the customer, the customer says this IP posted the bad thing, they take the new IP and go to the ISP, ISP hands over the original users details, they go knock on the users door.
It is basically a turd rolling down hill that nobody wants to touch and everyone wants to pass on to the next person. At each step YOU are responsible for the bad thing that happened until you give them a new person to look at.
If you think it works any differently, take a look at what happened to the "TheDonald" forum after January 6th. You can shout and scream about freedoms and rights all you want, but when your girlfriend has to explain to her boss why the FBI came around asking questions about you - you hand over the next guy down the line super quick.
You’re just making assumptions without referring to the facts.
Mullvad is a Swedish company and falls under Swedish and EU jurisdiction.
ISPs in the EU are indeed required to keep track on what subscriber had what IP at what point in time. Some do this gladly and some try their absolute best to sabotage the process (like Bahnhof).
However, Mullvad is a VPN provider. They are not an ISP. If you claim that Mullvad is legally required to log IPs, then source that claim, because they clearly are not and if that claim is true that would mean they are breaking the law, which I doubt they would be willfully doing.
In your example, the buck stops with the VPN provider (which again, is not an ISP) because the info they provide is of no use.
In some cases, the buck even stops with the ISP without a VPN, because in many jurisdictions there are demands placed upon the seriousness of the alleged crime to allow personal data to be supplied to law enforcement.
The whole "based in X country" is just a gimmick.
But you are really missing the forest for the trees here. If the crime against the US is serious enough, extra-judicial rendition is on the table. So is extra-judicial execution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Qasem_Soleima...
The idea of being based in a specific country giving you some sort of immunity is disingenuous.
What happened? I missed it.
You bring up a very good point. Unlike an electronic payment system [0], I assume the amazon gift card is not linked to your account on Mullvad's servers, so probably Mullvad marks the account as paid, but doesn't log the Amazon card number
0. Even that should be safe. Mullvad made a recent decision to get rid of subscriptions. Now that your account is never linked to your payment method, and we can assume that it's safe to use your personal credit/debit card. But I'd be careful, if someone is important, there is a possibility of someone tracking and logging their activities, credit card use, IPs before Mullvad purchase and after they connect.
In some jurisdictions, like Sweden (where Mullvad is based) there is such a thing as "help to commit a crime" that does get prosecuted
Unless you’re in an authoritarian regime where the courts simply follow the whims of the political leadership, selling SIM cards, gift cards for a VPN, knives or ski masks will hardly in separate cases by itself be considered obvious intent to assist criminal activity.
Nevermind the fact that you're at trial where a judge and jury is looking at this. Nevermind that the point the GP made was that if you have someone knocking on your door motivated to find something they will find something.
I am assuming if you are a nefarious actor, the goal is to not have this kind of attention, ever. You do this in all of the traditional ways - insulate and delegate.
If you buy these cards and re-sell them, you have plausible deniability. If you buy them from a re-seller you have increased anonymity.
Obviously the goal for a nefarious actor (or anyone, probably) is to not end up in court. But it’s objectively true that the idea of Amazon gift cards does in some scenarios actually give you increased anonymity compared to other payment options, if nothing else because of the timing offset if you want to disregard re-sellers.
Sounds extremely unlikely.
Buying a Mullvad gift card makes you at most a Mullvad customer. The cards are presumably one SKU, none of Amazon nor Mullvad know which one is sent to a given person.
I'm not sure what the connection might be to warrants here? Surely if a judge will sign on "hey this guy uses a VPN can we grab his laptop?", that judge would sign on any other flimsy excuse.
Step 2. They start looking for evidence
Step 3. They find uncommon actions you took to make your browsing history harder to track.
Step 4. Judge
Step 5. https://xkcd.com/538/
No one will prosecute you for using Mullvad but using it may be a red flag that you have something to hide if you’re already under investigation
Legal cases are not code, they are often fuzzy and loose, and rely on human interpretation, with all its biases and emotions, to draw a conclusion.
If the cops confiscate your computer and Mullvad is installed, and your Amazon account has a purchase history of Mullvad gift cards, your claim of “ive never used it before. Those cards were for someone else and I never used the software” won’t get you very far.
For example, "It wasn't me. A friend used my Wi-Fi!" and similar arguments will not fly as you can be seen as responsible as bill payer. Those kind of defenses could even be considered admissions of guilt.
It's concerning to see how many people suggest you claim your Wi-Fi was unprotected if accused of something. This will more likely be used against you if anything.
Even you get into account directly. You see the user using a code redeemed from gift card. And then?
You can't associate the code with anything at all even you also hack into mullvad's server. There is no way to tell that where the code was from even for Mullvad themselves let alone others as long as there is no serial number that also displays on card without scratch open it.
all that can be said with certainty is:
1. that these people bought mullvad cards on amazon.
2. these mullvad accounts were paid with cards
All you can say is that 2 is a subset of 1.
If mullvad sells the cards literally anywhere else, then you can't even say that with certainty.
Mullvad doesn’t even have to sell them anywhere else: anyone who bought one on Amazon could have re-sold it, individually or in bulk. That’s the clever part.
If i tried to claim in court I bought and resold, they'll expect to see the paper trail or judt dismiss my comment
The point is that you don’t have to do this, someone else can do it for another reason (namely profit) and the increased anonymity still applies compared to the other payment options.
There have been countless cases demonstrating that "no-log" VPN providers definitely do log, and even if by some miracle Mullvad doesn't, they can be compelled to start doing so, as the Protonmail case demonstrates.
This does nothing to reduce the paper trail.
If you really really really trust Mullvad (and you shouldn't), just use Monero.
The on-ramp to "just use Monero" isn't that simple for over 99% of users I'm guessing. Also, if they have your IP address logged, does it even matter how you paid?