It's almost perfect except for one almost deal breaker thing (which applies to both Giscus and utterance.es): to comment you have to click through a very scary permissions dialog that claims it can "Act on your behalf" in your Github account, without any qualification. I'm pretty sure the permissions dialog is misleading, but it sucks. I expect that it really cuts down on the number of people willing to leave a comment. And I doubt it will be fixed because Github probably doesn't really care to support this use of their API.