Unless it happened again already, it was a 9-10 year old, depending on whether you are referring to when she was raped or when she had left the state to get an abortion.
> Too many people treated it like a political point tally.
Side1: If your political position is enacted, Bad Thing will happen, hurting people.
Side2: You are inventing unlikely scenarios for political points, you aren't really concerned about the people that you pretend Bad Thing will happen to.
...Side2 policy adopted...
...Bad Thing immediately happens as predicted...
Side1: Look, Bad Thing just happened.
Side2: You don't care about the person Bad Thing happened to, you are just scoring political points.
Edit: I don’t think the time of the reports was particularly helpful. The day before the story was verified, someone had published an op-Ed in NYTimes titles “Laugh at my abortion with me.” Nobody’s laughing about a preteen being raped.
Odds are it has.
There should be a presumption of innocence in the sense that the public should assume the accused is innocent until evidence is publicly shared that suggests their guilt.
So far the only evidence shared with the public is a confession. Confessions are notoriously unreliability.
There will be more evidence. DNA tests are being done as we speak.
That is rape.
If the other party was some other person - then that 27 year old shouldn't be wrongly convicted, but someone raped that 10 year old. I, btw, haven't seen anyone chomping at the bit at the specific suspected other party - the discussion I've seen has been focused on the health care and trauma treatment for the 10 year old.
Right now the only evidence being presented is his confession: confessions suck as evidence. And it seems he is not a native English speaker. Non native English speakers are especially prone to false confessions (in America), because they don’t understand everything being said and signed.
“Sign this paper please, it’s a receipt for your goods. Now sign this paper, it’s consent to medical treatment by prison staff. Now sign this paper, it summarizes everything you told us so you won’t have to be questioned again.”
There are DNA tests being done as we speak. If raped her, the only way he’s getting away is if someone else raped her too and that other person impregnated her too (DNA is from fetus).
Need? No, you can’t force people to think things. Should? Yes, absolutely it should. People are accused of, but later found innocent of, crimes all the time.
The reason why I hold the political positions that I do at its foundations has the fact that I care if this is going on in the society that I live in, because I don't think anyone should have to go through that. Or ectopic pregnancies that can't be aborted, etc.
If you think I'm just trying to "score points" you're projecting. I don't support abortion in order to "own the Trumpers" and rub their noses in abortions, I really think it produces a worse society, with more suffering.
Even if they did care (unlikely as that is), there is no way to intervene in an arbitrary 11-year-old's healthcare.
The scope of action is in the design of the society that permits harm as defined in one way or the other. And that's politics. So people are acting in the only way that makes sense.