>So you are dismissing the idea that Ilya was depressed.
no, i'm dismissing the idea that suicide necessarily means a mental illness.
no, i'm dismissing the idea that suicide necessarily means a mental illness.
If the person is rational then problems can only be one of two kinds: situational (e.g. my life sucks because I owe more money than I stand to earn in 3 lifetimes) and health-related. The rational stance to the first kind would be to do as I suggest above. Obviously, in the second case escaping won't change anything so suicide could be a rational choice.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1341504/pdf/bmjc...