I was wondering if you could clarify this. Why is the caste system fair game to criticize but nepotism isn't?
I was wondering if you could clarify this. Why is the caste system fair game to criticize but nepotism isn't?
I have never seen a team lead by a WASP or Jewish manager that has hired exclusively WASP or Jewish team members in any FAANG company. I have however seen teams that are exclusively Indian, even in diverse cities. At some point it comes down to network for early stage companies. But why is this true in FAANG companies where hiring pipelines are robust?
Good example of association fallacy [1].
This means a whole lot of racist personnel decisions are being made in all directions, and in a diverse workplace they kind of net-out OK?
In any case, ignoring one awful problem because there are others that may be of higher magnitude (or may not...) doesn't seem like a good plan.
If I sort myself into an all-white cultural bubble, and then later hire all the people from my network into the groups I run, etc-- I end up making de-facto racist hiring decisions. So even the situation you describe does eventually trend towards racism.
And, in any case, I think back to one of my early experiences in industry. We had groups that were 95% one ethnicity. I am pretty sure based on organizational culture that I would not have been successful in one of the non-white ones, and I'm not sure that people from those groups would have been successful transplanted into in the majority white groups. I think in practice the organization was really bad from a DEI standpoint, but on paper probably looked really, really good.