To your point you can see that in last month lake Mead has been rising quite a bit[0]. Unlike lake Powell, I do not believe this rise is because of redirecting other water sources (please correct me if I am wrong). However you can see this increase is a long way from restoring, and the region is still considered under drought conditions (though less severe that it was earlier in year).
This was true and known even in the 1970s when I lived in Arizona.
What’s important to understand is water resources are averaged over a multi year period and a few months of normal rain isn’t enough to make things ok.
That said, much of the midwest’s water issues come from assumptions before wells dropped water levels in the region. A stream can gain or lose water based on the local water table so simply getting X rainfall per year doesn't guarantee a dam will continue receiving the same amount of water year after year. Worse models aren’t based on unlimited data, random events can mean you’re basing things in unusually good times, even ignoring climate change.
https://youtu.be/YhF9sOUpe9Y?t=1868
1931-1937 1959-1964 1988-1992 2000-2005 2012-present
Notice the increasing tempo of drought frequency? That's in line with long-term climate model predictions of the drying of the American Southwest, linked to a general trend of rising interior temperatures in midlatitude continental zones (in particular, decreased soil moisture, declining summer snowpack, possibly expanding Hadley cell circulation).
See also the 2000-present graph at the bottom of this page:
https://www.drought.gov/states/colorado
It might be true that these reservoirs could be refilled if most outflow was eliminated, but that would mean the end of regional agriculture and severe restrictions on household water use across the entire region.
Why do people always turn to regulation and rationing rather than simply increasing the price of water?
A more balanced option might be setting a minimal delivery baseline for everyone in the watershed, with prices rising steeply above that baseline for the remaining water. This would encourage adoption of recycling, aka 'toilet-to-tap'...
Many Americans have this bizarre fixation on the idea that markets are magic and freedom means that whoever has the most money gets whatever they want. Sorry but that is an incredibly cruel and inefficient way to make decisions.
The system of free market pricing has always been a more efficient and effective way to distribute scarce goods to where they are most needed.
The system of rationing has never produced fair or efficient results. If you disagree, present a system where rationing has done otherwise. Certainly, that has never worked for water distribution.
I mean that's the most obvious example. But really, this is a commonplace and standard practice- get out a cake at a birthday party and how are you going to divide it? Richest family gets the most cake?
This is a bad question to be honest, possibly asked in bad faith.
Let's take WW2 gas rationing. People were allocated gas based on their profession. Note that this had NOTHING to do with their needs. So what happened? Nobody had an allocation that matched their need, it was either too much or too little. So what happened? An illegal black market emerged where those with extra sold it to those with less (at high prices, as illegal markets always carry a price premium).
Let's take your birthday cake example. It has the same assumption built in - that everybody wants exactly the same amount of cake. This is never the reality, and forcing it on people results in inefficient mis-allocation, and people who want more saying "hey, are you going to finish yours? Can I have it?".
> possibly asked in bad faith
You might want to read up on the history of the results of rationing before you draw such conclusions.
And anyone is free to print unlimited quantities of their own private currency. This is completely legal. But no one else is obligated to accept it.
I hadn't noticed the US self-destructing. Maybe I read the wrong history books?
And our recent inflation - great job, government!
FWIW I tried the link and couldn't get it to generate data.
Not sure but around same time I think I also had some school teacher astronaut come and give our school a speech before she went up.
McAuliffe was to be the first teacher they sent to space, and they didn't try again until I think '98. Not sure if you realized that connection, but it was kind of surreal for me when it clicked that this is probably who you're talking about.
A few areas have gotten normal amount of snow or rain, but watersheds are huge and water is saved up over long timeframes. https://www.usbr.gov/lc/images/maps/CRBSmap.jpg
On a different note, I always appreciated the teaching from the local tribes about how being the source of these waters (multiple headwaters on west side of continental divide) was considered not just a privledge but even more important a responsibilty. Every thing you do upstream impacts tons of peoples downstream.
Also, I’m not sure how you’re missing the very acrimonious Colorado River negotiations b/t upper and lower basin states. Upper basin is refusing to commit to water use quotes in 2023, lower basin states aren’t addressing the root cause at all while asking for cuts (my bias - this how the upper basin probably should act without rational acknowledgement and concessions of why Co/WY/UT should sacrifice water for Almond farms in CA and Arizona suburban sprawl and golf courses in literal deserts).
If you’re not aware of how heated this is getting, you should check in. It’s about to shape a tremendous amount of water policy for us, however it turns out.