It's not disrespectful to argue that putting something on the internet doesn't make it public domain, no matter what _why thought or thinks. If _why doesn't want it taken down, he won't ask them to take it down. That doesn't mean that conversations about whether things put the internet become publicly owned, even sparked by someone bootlegging a defunct site under the original domain name, have to hinge on what _why thinks.
Or whether things put on the internet are any more publicly owned than books, television shows, or movies, which can all easily be put on the internet (and which everybody agrees is extremely problematic irt the law.)
edit: also, this really reeks of weird parasocial hero worship unless you know the man and have asked him about it.