My feeling is that the amount of surprised I had was brought about by the overwhelming marketing that WASI was basically this thing that gives you a capabilities based model for system calls, and in practice it was a semi-implemented, glorified markdown file that was not a part of any standardization process, at least not W3C draft..REC.
Now, I look at some of the tensions and they seem to imply this solved backend, but not frontend :) Well, I would say that it got backends turning, basically pushing the abstraction cliff a bit farther out than ad-hoc host ABIs times X targets. This surely was helpful as it allows people to get much farther along especially when everything uses llvm and libc. However, I hope what's next can do a bit more rigor as the first was an example of how to thrash a lot of people. spectest shouldn't be an optional thing in something called a standard, detailed mapping documents can happen to help people implement the paper and pass those tests. I think whatever happens next can fix things, and it will be both a matter of avoiding copy/pasta spec, but also adding far more rigor.
Regardless, I personally am happy to continue supporting who has used WASI and its alternatives including the next WASIs. Progress is important and I think WASI, albeit stumbling, progressed the backend a lot.
my 2p and thanks for the post!