5000 tons of Aluminum? so what? Aluminum is non-toxic as far as I know. Besides, won't these satellites will be completely disintegrated by the time they reach the ground? It's not like they're going to to be crashing into houses and stuff.
As for the brightness of the satellites, who cares? Can't you just write a computer program to track the satellites and exclude them from the picture? I can't imagine it's like they're shooting a long exposure on an analog camera.
This is like a NIMBY sort of complaint, where you have the opportunity to complain about it because you're aware of the few explicit downsides. Meanwhile all the massive implicit costs of accepting the alternative (terrestrial infrastructure) are swept under the rug. Out of sight- out of mind!