My own Flanders has hero Lieven Bouwens. There are huge lists of the USA 'importing' european knowhow before the world wars. Japan was a falous tech thief in the 1960's.
In most cases, the importer got better than the country of origin. Beware.
My own Flanders has hero Lieven Bouwens. There are huge lists of the USA 'importing' european knowhow before the world wars. Japan was a falous tech thief in the 1960's.
In most cases, the importer got better than the country of origin. Beware.
Furthermore, this take is the “neutral global citizen” way of looking at things. It’s one perspective, and certainly important to be aware of, but China vs US (or the west more generally) isn’t a neutral outcome.
The Chinese system would be a massive detriment to human rights if allowed to continue growing, as it’s a massive detriment to human rights now. “Retweeting” pro-western perspectives is the right thing to do in that case, even if it isn’t the most “neutral” perspective.
For some reason there’s a fear of being pro-western nowadays and so many like to take this “enlightened observer” approach, but that’s a luxury existing in the west affords, and keeping it requires defending it.
1) They did it. That's all that matters. We'll have to deal with that as a fact. Trying to use moral labels will not help anybody.
2) A top country screams theft. Meanwhile all the other country's including but not limited to China know that top country stole just as much when it wasn't at the top of the ladder. They can and will rightfully call the top country out not applying equal measures. Retweeting only half of the truth is hypocritical, they know it, and they'll use it to gain political advantage against the 1st world. It does not make us 'enlightened observers' simply for pointing this out.
3) While China is far from a beacon of human rights, this kind of tech transfer used to be the kickoff for more human rights in the countries where it happened. After Lieven Bouwens in Flanders etc there was massive worker abuse up to killing children in factories. Everybody knew things where blatantly unfair. The workers organized and demanded rights (The whole story about priest Daens in our history). I understand the US had its own Robber Barons, and a lot of western countrys have similar stories. Why would China be different?
If that’s how you feel, then don’t spread it, but when the stakes are as high as the future of billions of lives, neutrality or forwarding the most despotic perspective makes you in part culpable for what they do.
most importantly, stop projecting American imperialist attitudes onto China. there is zero indication of China trying to spread the systems you are so afraid of.
funny how the "neutral global citizen" is interested in preserving a system that just happens to benefit the west at the expense of the global south.
Zero? Not convincing.
China expanding the territory of its recent political and social systems looks clear to people watching from outside China. Examples: Tibet, Hong Kong recently, and Taiwan is officially a someday target. Nearby countries understandably worry they are on the someday list as well, more since South China Sea activities and the artificial islands being constructed.
China calls these system expansions "internal" because everywhere the systems expand to is deemed "really" China already. But most people who live there didn't (or don't) want it, and have lost (or would lose) access to ways of life, human rights and freedoms that they previously had and cherished that are under discussion in this thread.
(It's a bit like Russia's view that Ukraine is "really" part of Russia so the invasion is not an invasion, and the annexation of Crimea was not an annexation. Whatever you think of history, one way or another those actions obviously spread the current Russian system to more territory and people, most of whom don't want it. The parallels to China and Taiwan (and previously China and Tibet) are strong enough that many words have been written saying that's why China chose not to condemn Russia in either case.)
No one even disputes Chinese sovereignty over Tibet and Hong Kong, as far as I'm aware.
Everyone recognizes that Taiwan has legally been part of China since 1945 (it became part of China in the 1680s, but Japan took it as a prize of war in 1895 and had to give it back at the end of WWII). The complication there is that China had a civil war, the former government of China retreated to Taiwan, and the territory has grown apart over the decades.
But it's not as if China is just randomly making up territories to claim. It's claiming very specific territories that it has a strong legal claim to.
Legal claims, justified or not, are imho irrelevant to the current discussion point, which is whether China wishes to spread its political and social systems to large numbers more people, and whether there is an international ethical obligation to resist that. That's why I mentioned the parallel with Russia, which "claims" Ukraine. That claim is irrelevant: Even if the legal claim was justified, it would still be an invasion, because the Ukrainians don't want to be invaded or be subjgated to Russian rule.
> No one even disputes Chinese sovereignty over Tibet
That statement is false: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tibetan_sovereignty_debate
A great many people have disputed Chinese sovereignty over Tibet ever since the annexation of 1959, and they still dispute it and protest against Chinese rule. As for "spreading of systems": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinicization_of_Tibet
> and Hong Kong
Legal sovereignty of a sort is not disputed there. But it does come tainted, as China took control on the condition of a "two systems" treaty about how to treat the people before the handover, and broke that treaty soon after. It is not clear the territorial handover would have occurred so easily if it was known in advance that China would dishonour its commitment to the people. As a result of breaking that treaty, it can be said that China has in fact violated some aspects of territorial legal sovereignty in Hong Kong, because those aspects were not China's legal right to take.
But "legal claims" and "specific territories" have no bearing on the point of discussion in this thread, which is whether China has "zero" ambition to spread its political and social systems
Tibet and Hong Kong are examples where it has spread its recent political and social systems to large numbers more people than before, removing cherished human rights and freedoms from them against their will. It says it wants to do it in Taiwan. So "zero" ambition to spread its systems is nonsense.
I think your argument is that other countries don't need to worry about China spreading its systems further. That may or may not be justified, it's hard to tell. The South China Sea activities could have been collaborative projects with other countries in the region, but they are not, and that understandably makes those countries wary. China does not have a recent history of being particularly trustworthy (Hong Kong broke that), or sane (the "diplomacy" around Taiwan is bonkers), and talk of its ambitions being limited will be taken by some as merely a way to gain their cooperation until it's sufficiently powerful to change its mind.
In any case, the discussion was about people and ethics, and the spread of political and social systems which take away rights and freedoms, and where there's an ethical obligation towards those people. I think there's a good case for countries, legal claims, and historical control, being irrelevant to that.
I'm not really referring to private individuals here. I'm referring to organizations that matter, like countries, the UN, etc. Individuals can have whatever opinion they'd like, but there's no question at all in the international arena about whether Tibet is part of China.
> Indeed, legal sovereignty of a sort is not disputed there.
Not just "of a sort." Chinese territorial sovereignty over Hong Kong isn't disputed at all. Whether China is upholding its treaty with the UK is an entirely different question, but that question doesn't impact whether Hong Kong is part of China.
> I think your argument is that other countries don't need to worry about China spreading its systems further.
China is interested in regaining control over the territories that it considers to be China. These aren't far-flung parts of the world. They are close-by territories that have historically (not just in the distant past, but even in the post-war era) been internationally recognized as being part of China. China isn't about to claim California. It thinks Taiwan is part of China because Taiwan was (and still is) part of the Republic of China, to which the People's Republic considers itself the successor.
If you go looking for UN views on whether Tibet is "part of" China, you will find plenty of dissent in various UN working groups and such, and if you read into the subtlety of diplomats working on the things that actually matter, you'll find people avoid saying one way or another because the things that matter don't involve the silly concept "part of", and because China freaks out uncooperatively if anyone mentions it, so it's better for dealing with real issues for people to avoid mentioning it. Even if they think it.
If you only look at formal views, via resolutions and such, I argue (as do many) those are just part of the diplomatic machinery. They don't define truth, or say what people actually think.
> that question doesn't impact whether Hong Kong is part of China.
I argue that whether Hong Kong is "part of" China is irrelevant to the question of whether China has (or had) ambitions to spread its systems over more people than before.
But since you bring up legal sovereignty, the question of whether China has the legal right to control the Hong Kong people in the way that it does, against their will and achieving it by dishonour and deception, is not as clear cut as you make out. The treaty being associated with the handover certainly has bearing on that. China broke international law in Hong Kong (not that international law is enforcible of course), and the very concept of legal sovereignty is founded on international agreements. If you don't honour agreements upon which the concept is founded, words like "legal sovereignty" don't mean anything anyway.
> to which the People's Republic considers itself the successor
Which again is about legal and political claims and such, and therefore irrelevant to the question of whether China desires to spread its present day political and social systems to more people.
Indeed, "considers itself the successor" implies that it does want to spread its systems to more people that don't want them.
This is about as ambiguous as American sovereignty over Hawaii. Yes, there are private individuals who question it, but that is not the position taken by any government or major international institution that I'm aware of. As for "subtle" statements, the US, UK and many other countries have made very unsubtle, definitive statements that they recognize Chinese sovereignty over Tibet.
> If you don't honour agreements upon which the concept is founded, words like "legal sovereignty" don't mean anything anyway.
Countries violate their treaty obligations all the time. Sovereignty is sacrosanct, and not something a country loses because it doesn't fulfil the conditions of one or another treaty. Britain can complain about China's treaty violations, and it can even take reciprocal actions (and it has), but it can't, for example, claim that sovereignty over Hong Kong has reverted to the UK.
> Indeed, "considers itself the successor" implies that it does want to spread its systems to more people that don't want them.
Only inside China.
The first is hard for me to accept, as a Westerner attached to direct democracy, but I recognize its accomplishments and try to look through the fog of propaganda.
The second is a an alternative to the Western, 'rules-based', neo-liberal and neo-colonial order. You're likely to see a large part of the world supportive of this alternative. It also leaves plenty of space for human rights and democracy in partner countries, since national sovereignty and multipolarity are amongst its guiding principals.
Here's what the PRC says about its democratic processes http://www.news.cn/english/2021-12/04/c_1310351231.htm
Having spoken to a bunch of Chinese people, they confirm many of these aspects. If anything it's a more direct form of democracy, where you elect local representatives that you have the opportunity to know personally, which then can get delegated to higher (up to national) bodies.
I have read about the positive aspects of the Chinese system of representation and the iterative improvements that it's intended to introduce. Definitely some things to learn from that approach.
Still, I can't go so far as to call it direct democracy and it's not just semantics or my reference to the Swiss system. Here is my reasoning. The Chinese government (central, provincial or local) is known for some heavy handed tactics that just wouldn't pass in a direct democracy where the people is sovereign.
Example: China's anti-coronavirus measures. (I am not arguing for or against but the case illustrates the mechanism.) I see no evidence that a large majority of Chinese citizens support those measures. In Switzerland, it was clear that the majority supporting measures was razor thin and this led to significant compromises. Primarily because there would have been more and more democratic initiatives seeking to limit government action and some would be successful. Neighbouring countries with less direct democracy do not feel this pressure and do not move so quickly.
We're all painfully aware of how many countries the US did that to, since most of were born in one.
How do you figure? It's funny, the vast majority of the complaints I see about China and human rights are things that the US is even worse about...
Chinese culture emphasizes harmony. The don't want war/conflict generally. Even when China was the most powerful country on Earth, they did not try to colonize and expand like the Europeans did.
But to an American, a powerful country means it will probably invade and start wars. This is the American way.
(And many others, of course.)