"But the only party stopping that comparison here is really Google."
When Google would release the stats, would you believe them?
There are a lot of stories about comparisons lately. I've seen a lot on HN and here is one from Spacetime Studios (Pocket Legends): http://blogs.computerworld.com/17941/android_ios_app_profit I think it's a fair comparison. The game got very good reviews on both platforms.
But I also like the last quote: "In some ways, it's kind of like the wild, wild West" It's a new area and maybe it's too soon to make any meaningful conclusions.