Not that I agree or disagree with this argument - just wanted to point out what their reasoning seems to be.
Not that I agree or disagree with this argument - just wanted to point out what their reasoning seems to be.
Their reasoning is the best that they could come up with under pressure. Which is to say - lol.
This is kind of a ridiculous comparison. A real-world landlord is a private individual extracting rent from their tenants while a real-world fire department is a publicly funded institution with a duty to protect everyone.
Cloudflare offers both its hosting and DDOS services as a private company. They aren't morally obligated to provide anything, regardless of whether the DDOS protection is offered for free.
Is that so wrong? Isn't that better than the alternative? Maybe, if we lived in a world where the government provided CDNs and DDoS mitigation and DNS zone file hosting and resolution and such, then its a reasonable argument to say: We have an entity beholden to Higher Laws which we can hold responsible, and marginalized voices have recourse when they're failed by private infrastructure.
We don't live in that world, and its not on the radar. Sure, private companies aren't beholden to Free Speech laws. But maybe its better that some opt-in to a standard higher than "if Jassy hasn't had his coffee this morning we better have an extra on-call SRE". Or, more commonly: when deplatforming decisions are made either by a blackbox AI written by engineers who left 2 years ago, or Twitter outrage.
Cool, but they're not.