That said, open source drivers are not enough, need proper hardware programing manuals with erratas.
The first thing I would do is trash android for a homebrew elf/linux derivative.
Written by whom? I don’t think you can even fathom the complexity of modern phone SoCs. They make an x86 PC look like an oversimplified teaching exercise. And even x86 PCs aren’t as well supported by Linux as by commercial OSs. Fun to dream but the likelihood of this statement coming true is zero.
But also what does open source driver mean here - does it mean for any OS, public domain, etc? Because if so then you’re talking about the government requiring people to give up their property.
From a consumer protection perspectiv, it seems completely reasonable to say hardware devices have to have FOSS drivers, and that all hardware/software errata must be documented in public for at least N years.
That could be watered down by only requiring the open sourcing / public docs when the manufacturer decides to drop driver support for the current release of the phone OS.
> From a consumer protection perspectiv, it seems completely reasonable to say hardware devices have to have FOSS drivers, and that all hardware/software errata must be documented in public for at least N years.
Why?
> That could be watered down by only requiring the open sourcing / public docs when the manufacturer decides to drop driver support for the current release of the phone OS.
Again why? If your device still functions why should the manufacturer be required to give up ownership of their IP?
Ending support for software on a network connected device is practically equivalent to revoking the license to the software that came with the device — it renders the device unfit for purpose.
Requiring manufacturers to support everything forever is probably infeasible/uneconomical.
There are precedents for using source code escrow to protect investors / purchasers in situations where companies become insolvent. Those same mechanisms could be used to protect consumers from phone manufacturers that decide to drop device support.
Mandating FOSS licensing once the escrow agreement seems practical.
Can you have a better legislative solution for ensuring phone operating systems are maintained in perpetuity?
And device drivers for android, at minimum, since the ASOP folks could use them now. Linux would be great because it would eventually thrive in an environment like that.
Grandma can't fix a car either but she can at least get the tyres changed without paying the car's rrp and getting someone to heat it up within a few degrees of exploding, or drive it on a new road without it having a tantrum.
I said that this action by the EU will not result in more sustainable consumption, which seems to be the reason behind it. I wouldn't oppose forcing phones to be more open in order to increase their lifespan, but I also wouldn't expect that to increase sustainability.
We want to be able to replace the battery ourselves cheaply with third party batteries if we want, or carry spares, and update the drivers and OS indefinitely, even if we have to do it ourselves. We want to replace a screen, or a board without getting our property bricked.
Those phones had “mysterious” shutdown issues with ~20% battery remaining that started being reported about 6 months after release (when it was still the latest iPhone). Those same issues were somehow fixed with a software update, but not before the shutdowns made a bunch of customers angry.
It’s obvious that Apple simply under-specced the batteries, not that they were trying to make the phone wear out early.
Further, the wikipedia page for planned obsolescence (read the defintion they have, it screams Apple) references the Apple battery lawsuits in 'see also'. That should be enough I think? Included in that list are quite a few other bad practices that Apple engages in! Kinda fun to read the list with Apple in mind. Vendor lock in, right to repair, crippleware (battery software degredation), phobeus cartel (5 years of computer life down from infinite), and more! Its almost just a list of shitty stuff Apple (and other modern phone companies) do. Wow, theyre bad sports.
Denial doesn't get us anything but shitty quality phones by shitty companies.