N9 was released in 2011, by that time Nokia was already dead.
Trolltech was acquired in 2008. Nokia could have have a modern alternative to iOS and Android from day 1 but they made the terrible mistake of reinventing the wheel and trusting Gnome.
Harmattan (Maemo 6 branded as MeeGo that shipped with N9) was Qt based from the start. Gtk wasn't officially supported at all there, although some support has been brought over by the community.
Also, I guess you have never actually used Qtopia? I did. It wasn't really a great base to build a smartphone platform on. It made a great feature phone though, and was a pretty nice demonstration platform for Qt Embedded. Nokia didn't have Qtopia until they brought Trolltech, which happened after several versions of Maemo were already shipped in working products.
The burning platform memo was the worst of all: lots and lots of mobile app developers intended to develop for Maemo as the third platform because Nokia was still a huge leader and they trusted Nokia. The moment Elop announced Nokia was shifting to Windows Phone, with phones months away, and no possibility of reusing any code from another platform (only .NET allowed, no way to reuse any C/C++ base they were sharing on Android and iOS), that was the moment everybody dropped Nokia. Suicide.
You mean, what Om2008 tried to do? ;]
And what the problems were with gnome? In 2009, the N900 was based on GTK and was a solid base to build on.
The N900 had pretty good reviews and 2 more years of work could likely have made it even better. And Nokia had the developers and control to do what they wanted however arogant Gnome developers were.
I have developed for neither, so I can't really say.
That said, I have been using Gnome based desktop for 10 years now, so I'm bias towards it.