- "Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." (you went on a quintessential generic flamewar tangent)
- "Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." (you did exactly the thing that we added this rule to discourage)
Can you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules? They're designed to avoid the tedious, repetitive flamewars this kind of thing leads to.
p.s. I'm not saying that such phrases aren't provocative—they are provocative. That's why we (HN commenters) have to be the ones to interrupt the predictable provocation process, if we're going to have the interesting, curious, diffy* conversations that this site is supposed to be for.
* https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
I'm not going to ban you for it right now but if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to using HN as intended in the future, we'd appreciate it. That means a lot of things, but most importantly it means using the site primarily out of curiosity. Curiosity and battle are disjoint motivations.
>Note that bullying appears to be related to power differentials more than to gender, meaning that the reason why perpetrators are overwhelmingly male is because men disproportionally occupy powerful academic positions. Obviously, women in powerful positions can be bullies, too [[29, 30]].
I am a cisgender, straight, white male in tech (not in academia) and I don't think it's a big deal to acknowledge that I benefit from quite a few privileges as such. I don't get harassed sexually, noone bats an eye when I mention my partner, society doesn't expect me to bear children, I have a very decent income, I get a default level respect for my technical abilities just by virtue of showing up.
I have many friends in leftist, queer, activist circles and don't feel demonized in the slightest. What I do, and I don't feel diminished at all by doing so, on the contrary, is learn and listen to how people not having all these characteristics have a wildly different life experience. If someone rails against white patriarchy or whatever, realize that that is very much a thing in many people's experience, and you might be blind to it by virtue of being a white man.
The great thing about intersectionality is that even if you're a white man, that is not all you are. You can use an intersectional framework to address areas where you are indeed a minority, be it because of your financial background, physical or mental disabilities, physical or mental illnesses, etc... Being a white man, yet an immigrant in the US, is a different experience than being a citizen.
I always find it puzzling that critics think that intersectional studies are about vilifying "all white men", when the premise is actually the opposite. A white man with mental illness from a working class background would not be part of the "very narrowly defined group that enjoys intersectional privilege". Nor does enjoying the intersectional privilege assume that you are a harasser, a bad person, just that other people probably encountered harassment more often than you.
I think where people get lost is rhetoric. You're getting lost because:
> I am a cisgender, straight, white male in tech (not in academia) and I don't think it's a big deal to acknowledge that I benefit from quite a few privileges as such. I don't get harassed sexually, noone bats an eye when I mention my partner, society doesn't expect me to bear children, I have a very decent income, I get a default level respect for my technical abilities just by virtue of showing up.
You believe this is uniform enough that it can be said definitively. They're getting lost because they see the subject continually brought up but then walked back with statements like:
> Note that bullying appears to be related to power differentials more than to gender, meaning that the reason why perpetrators are overwhelmingly male is because men disproportionally occupy powerful academic positions. Obviously, women in powerful positions can be bullies, too [[29, 30]].
All that tells me is that we don't really know how to talk about any of this correctly yet.
You asked why people get triggered over this, this is my hypothesis. Don't take that for me not liking intersectionality.
It's very much a racist statement in my book. Of course, that's the core of the intersectional ideology, a racist ideology. The first and most important divider when it comes to classes is wealth. Identity politics as practiced by intersectionalists served the elite well.
If one pushes that obnoxious and absurd intersectional logic to its paroxysm, then one can deem people from jewish origin "at the intersection of privilege". Sounds antisemitic? Indeed, because that whole ideology is indeed racist at its core, under pretense of "social justice".
The topic of "whiteness" comes up in a small section of the article that discusses the fact that there has been far less reporting of the phenomenon than would be expected from how "open" this secret is. You can agree or disagree with whether whiteness or maleness has much to do with it, but you can't reasonably disagree with the broader point of that section of the article: academic STEM research is way worse than you'd expect looking at it as an outsider.
Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
This is a particularly egregious instance, because this article discusses a phenomenon that should be especially interesting to HN (overwhelmingly widespread abuse in academic science labs), and yet here we are bickering over whether the article used the word "whiteness" appropriately in one paragraph.
Also, I would say that you're comments in this subthread do not assume the strongest possible interpretation of the commenters point. You're coming across as actively hostile, frankly.
In fact, at most scientific conferences, Antarctica is usually the only continent not represented, so it's doubly unusual for academics to suddenly become so blinkered.
The same as red politics it's designed to be a "you're X so your reasons and facts don't matter.".
Unfortunately universities are filled with warm bodies and students that cannot survive in the private sector. Therefore they need tax funding to get paid to do research. Grants are based on what's politically popular, and so here we are.
An easy way to resolve this will be to remove federal student loans. They're predatory and cause students to spend their lives in an echo chamber of psuedo science at tax payer expense.