Btw, it had a thorough discussion when it was first published: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17523056. That one was on the front page for 5 hours, so it got even more attention the second time around.
In case anyone's wondering, your comment was flagged by users, not mods.
I booked an apartment in a big city, on the day I arrived the host cancelled. I got my money back and was stranded and had to get a same-day accommodation for a way higher price, which also took a lot of time of my short trip time to figure out. Of course this is covered by their ToS and according to them, perfectly legit for hosts to do. But as a traveler I want to have some kind of security that I will actually have a place to stay, so I stick with Booking.com, because they guarantee a place to stay even if the host cancels.
2. You're entitled to your opinion, Airbnb's success would suggest you're an outlier. Airbnb matches renters and property owners. It's essentially a craigslist for rentals. It's allowed me to book cool spots I never could have before. Good enough for me and millions others.
3. This a result of the cost of good customer service being greater than the benefit to Airbnb. I wish McDonalds was white glove and served cigars and brandy after the meal, but its not the market they're in.