These days, it's looking like renewables + storage could supply "synthetic baseload" more cheaply than nuclear in most places (maybe not Finland, yet; that part of the world is one of the worst for renewables), so there's not much place left for nuclear. If your energy system has variable demand it will need storage even with nuclear, which tilts the game toward renewables even further (their need for storage is partially covered by the storage one needs anyway to level the load; said storage can level supply and demand at the same time, to some extent.)
Nuclear also has the problem that it's not going to survive very well as a niche technology, as that would likely not cause enough construction of new power plants to keep the industry from seeing negative learning effects.
That is not true. Nuclear power has been used as a dispatchable / regulative source of power to compensate solar and wind power intermittency for decades in France.[1]
> These days, it's looking like renewables + storage could supply "synthetic baseload" more cheaply than nuclear in most places
And that's gross bullshit.
- Never storage of electricity has been deployed successfully at scale needed for a mid size country. Pretend that it is, today, a solution is highly hypocritical or plain gross bullshit.
- Even on the most optimistic (and untested) scenario, the cost plan of RE+Storage is (at best) on part with Nuclear energy (Pumped-storage) and or way more expensive (battery, power2gas). [2]
> maybe not Finland, yet; that part of the world is one of the worst for renewables
That is even more bullshit. Finland has pretty large hydro reserves. Renewable does not stop to solar. [3]
[1]: https://hal-edf.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01977209/document
[2]: https://www.powermag.com/how-much-will-hydrogen-based-power-...
[3]: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/FI?solar=false&remote=t...
Remember folks -- according to nuclear defenders, nothing can ever happen for the first time. At least, when it comes to renewables, that is. Except for all the times new milestones are reached, I guess.
There is no valid technical reason you can point to that would prevent a 100% renewable grid from operating. And the cost of all the components have been falling rapidly as demand pushes them down their experience curves. I might forgive you for ignoring that, as a good experience curve is sadly not something nuclear has had, in general.
Also:
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=983...
> With every iteration in the research and with every technological breakthrough in these areas, 100% RE systems become increasingly viable. Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels.
(since nuclear is not available at a cost similar to fossil fuels, this implies renewables would be less costly than nuclear)
That is sophism and what-aboutism and irrelevant.
> There is no valid technical reason you can point to that would prevent a 100% renewable grid from operating.
There is and it is named Energy Storage.
A renewable energy system to power the world would be an enormous undertaking. It's just that it would be less expensive than a nuclear system to do the same.
How much energy storage can we buy for 20 billion right now?
Where in Finland are suitable sites?
What are the costs per MWh to store and release energy from it?
You take the most expensive energy source and run it at a lower capacity factor leading to even higher costs per delivered kWh. That is the issue.
Say you run Hinkley Point C [1] at a capacity factor of 50% because renewables crowd it out of the market half the time and assume marginal costs of running the plant at ~€20/MWh. [2]
€(120 - 20) * 2 + 20 = €220/MWh.
That would be expensive even by Putin energy crisis standards, that is the issue with mixing nuclear and renewables.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...
[2]: https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
Very bad projection because:
- Hinkley Point C, Olkiluoto 3 and EPR Flamanville are all prototype. Their CAPEX cost are not representative of industrialized Nuclear. As example, the production cost as expressed by the French ARENH is around 42-1€/MWh [1]
- Electricity price skyrocket when weather conditions make production of renewable impossible. This is where this kind of plant make a profit. [2] Your projection just fit a worst case scenario.
- At the current electricity price due to the Russian conflict, Some EPRs including the French ones are predicted to be cost effective in only few years.
[1]: https://www.enerdata.net/publications/daily-energy-news/fran...
[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-16/german-po...
No idea about Hinkley Point but TVOs 2 earlier reactors have costs in the 15 to 20€/MWh range with average market prices around 30 to 40€/MWh they are making healthy profits with the reactors (and have for decades now). Once OL3 is running their target combined operational costs of all the reactors are around 30€/MWh. It will be tight but they should be able to make it profitable especially as they don't have to sell all the production at day ahead spot prices but higher fixed rate contracts far into the future. Obviously nuclear also produces at the moments when wind does not and the price spikes.
(https://www.tvo.fi/material/collections/20210713150018/7Rllf... scroll down to page 7)
edit: And TVO does not actually sell anything on the open markets but instead at production costs to its owners based on the % of investment into each reactor. Those can then either sell it or use it themselves.
That is simply the operating cost. Yes, nuclear can be quite competitive if your reactor is provided for free by the Nuclear Fairy.
So in this case the nuclear fairy is the market buying the electricity just like for all forms of electricity it should be.
But if the question being asked is "should we build more nuclear reactors", then construction and financing costs must be included.
here is a newer one from Q2 this year https://www.tvo.fi/material/collections/20220713160120/7aj2c...
On the page 8 in the graph you can see the cash costs (operational costs) in blue and capital costs in purple (pink? dunno I'm quite badly color blind). Still with both of those the total costs of all 3 reactors is projected to be sub 40€/MWh. Obviously 40€/MWh is not ideal as the market every now and then is under that but they should be able to cover that during the moments when the price is high (it averages out they hope). Basically as long as the squiggly price line is above the colored solid area at the bottom profit is being made.
Also to the owners of the plant a easily predictable price is more important then the lowest so they can better predict operational costs of their billion euro+ paper pulp factories etc.
This report is based on their financial reporting to their share holders so I doubt they are lying.
You can find more at https://www.tvo.fi/en/index/investors/financialpublications....
edit: The math is quite simple for example 2021
14 414 000 MWh produced at the cost of 19€/MWh and average market price of 72.2€/MWh gets you 1 040 690 800€ of sold electricity at the cost of 273 866 000€ and capital costs of 220 000 000€ (OL3) giving them a profit of (well value made to their share holders who they sold the electricity to at cost of production) 546 824 800€
Not exactly like this as OL1 and OL2 do not have the exact same investor(s) and the split as OL3 but in the ballpark.
Could the investors have made a better profit by putting that 5.5 billion a decade ago in some random index fund or building wind mills? Maybe? But this is the gamble they took and seems to be profitable. Obviously not necessarily the most profitable investment as that is impossible to know at the moment you make the investment.
Funnily enough TVO (the owner and operator of Olkiluoto the site where his new reactor is at) also owns a bunch of hydro (and a little bit of wind). Though the hydro mostly exists as their own private backup generator. It has direct lines to the nuclear site so in the case they need to shutdown all the reactor and can't receive electricity from the grid to run the cooling systems they can get the electricity from that (they obviously also have onsite diesel generators too)