In declining to appear, their CEO traded the ability to refute statements in real time alongside Mudge for the ability to release carefully crafted statements after the fact that will receive public scrutiny but do not require him to tell the truth in response to any questions from congress, the content of which are out of his control. Misleading public statements can get them in hot water with regulators, but lying to congress is a crime.
It's probably a smart move, and it's certainly not unfair to Twitter.
Bloomberg: Grassley says Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal declined an invitation to appear today. Kurt Wagner Tech Reporter
Let's be real: Twitter is a huge cesspool of harassment, hosts a ton of pornography (including from children), and clearly has monetization/business problems. It also seems to have much worse engineering than other social businesses. It's going to be a lot harder to defend in one of these sessions than Facebook.
For the porn: So do Reddit and Facebook, with the latter having had multiple lawsuits by former content moderators for the uncountable amount of CSAM and gore [1]. The first "most popular" subreddit was r/NSFW, followed by r/gonewild - Reddit literally got big with porn.
As for harassment: Facebook with its closed groups is just as bad if not worse for radicalization (simply because way more people use it and no one monitors these groups, not to mention open channels such as newspaper comment sections), with direct links to deadly unrest such as in India [2]. Meta's other products are a horror show in themselves - Whatsapp has a history with mobs riled up by fake news to the point these have their own Wikipedia listicle [3] and Instagram has been under fire for years in helping to aid eating disorders [4].
It's bad enough that there are so many bad actors on Twitter, but the simple fact that Facebook makes billions of dollars in profit each year and doesn't even come close to the amount of moderation they would need makes them even worse.
[1] https://www.vice.com/en/article/a35xk5/facebook-moderators-a...
[2] https://www.dw.com/en/india-facebook-under-the-microscope-ov...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_WhatsApp_lynchings
[4] https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/News/instagram-eating-disorders-d...
In a country that values freedom of speech and association, this is considered a feature, not a bug.
The point there is that had we lived in a country where censoring speech was legal, there's every reason to believe even speaking of e.g. abolition could have landed you in jail, or worse. Would this have deterred change? Maybe, maybe not. But the one thing is for sure is that it'd have made the country a far less free place for everybody.
It seems that much of the world has forgotten or willfully ignore these lessons.
The cost of freedom is that people will use it to do things you don't like.
Freedom isn't necessary for a society to function, lots of societies function without it, and have for most of human history.
Given the choice though, I prefer to live in a society that chooses to maximize liberty. Without freedom of speech, all other liberties are irrelevant.
There's a reason why it's the first amendment.
Your country is barely 300 years old and has had a single constitution for its whole existence. The US has learned _no_ lessons through its existence. It's a country founded by colons who didn't want to pay taxes to the UK. The amount of lessons the US can give the world is about... none.
I'm German. My ancestors should have shown the world just enough on where not restricting hate speech and conspiracy crap leads: into murder, into genocide, into the dissolution of democracy itself.
It's astonishing that the US hasn't realized this as well after Jan 6th. You all don't realize just how fucking close you came and how thin the edge is you all are standing on.
In the history of German regimes, perhaps take a look at the degree to which each one suppressed free expression, and think about which were better.
Holocaust denial is banned in the majority of European countries, and at least in some countries Nazi symbolics are banned as well [1].
I live maybe an hour away from the KZ Dachau and have visited it. It's hard to have any other stance than "antisemitism, racism and other similar discrimination must be banned at all costs" when you personally see the evidence just how depraved humans can be.
Let humans go unchecked and you get anything from online mobs driving trans people to suicide (Kiwifarms) over murder (Heather Heyer) and lone wolf terrorism (Christchurch) and finally, a putsch attempt. Then, once a strongman/dictator has taken over, you will eventually see ethnic cleansings and genocide (see e.g. Russia's Ukraine invasion).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_Holocaust_denial
You really think that the police, especially federal police, would have disobeyed a direct request from the President asking them to stand down? There were only two completely random things that prevented an utter disaster at Jan 6th: Eugene Goodman, the brave cop redirecting the mob away just mere minutes after the Senate chamber was sealed [1], likely saving the Senators' lives, and Bobby Engel from the Secret Service [2], who reportedly resisted physical violence by the President himself and did not drive him to the Capitol as requested.
Had Trump been at the Capitol, I have absolutely zero doubt he would have crowned himself President that day - and that neither the Republican leadership nor the courts would have objected to this.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/goodman-c...
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/28/trump-lunged-at-secret-servi...
Also, you should check your sources (or rather, your sources' sources): there's a lot of fake news out about 1/6, a lot of it from "reliable" sources. The second story there is single-sourced from someone who wasn't in Trump's car whose story was disproven by someone who was actually in the car. The same outlets have been repeating the lie that one of the Trumpkins killed a capitol police officer with a fire extinguisher.
This takes me back to my German friends confidently predicting that the election of George W. Bush was the dawn of Nazi America. No, George W. Bush isn't going to roll the army out of Iraq and conquer the entire Middle East. No, Trump isn't going to disband the free press with the assent of Congress. No, the Capital Police, who work for Congress, are not going to stand down and let rioters run rampant, and no, neither Republican leadership (which wasn't in charge of Congress in any case) nor the courts are going to let anyone crown himself president.
All of those are actual predictions I heard from Germans. Trump did crown himself president, with the result any American would have predicted: he was derided and ignored by the majority of the country, and the location wouldn't have mattered at all to that.
I totally get given your country's history why this stuff comes up. But some of it is very, very alien to an American cultural consciousness. It turns out countries differ from one another.
It's worth reading about the relationship between Trump and his generals to understand the attitude that the American military takes, and is expected and required by their oath to take, toward the president.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/08/15/inside-the-war...
I am definitely not saying that fascism can't happen here. I'm saying that if it does it won't look like anything predictable from German history because there are vastly different cultural norms to bulldoze.
You are right to say that the impact falls on the marginalized. You are wrong to blame the free speech policy for that.
Good.
It is an indefensible house of cards where it can take someone like Mudge to just blow it up and give the regulators a reason to give a massive fine and put them under strict rules to do better, and they should give them massive fines.
The only reason this one is different is because of the specter of Elon Musk's acquisition falling through.
Repubs want free speech (unbanning of conservatives, Trump), Dems want control (what can and can't be said on the platform).
Bottomline, Ain't happening
Their staff and advisors most certainly are not. When Sen Orrin Hatch is asking stupid questions about facebook and ads, it's most certainly an act. For the benefit of the blue hairs back home.
As a former activist, I assume any public hearing is performance art.
Personal anecdote. One time the rules were suspended and I was allowed to testify about a bill being considered. I pointed out the vendor they were about to award an important contract appeared to be out of business. No phone, website offline, offices shuttered.
(I had prev made sure some contacts from the local media were present.)
Whoops!
Immediate recess. Hour later they reconvene. That bill is promptly tabled and onto next order of business. Exactly zero comment made about the matter.
That council never repeated the mistake of letting me go off script.
but Twitter has already testified more or less through compliance statements and attestations about their security, and now we’re finding out about what they’ve been sweeping under the rug.
And they also control a big megaphone. If they want to release a statement, they can tweet it and boost it directly into everyone's feed.
All it takes is this experienced security professional to bring down the house of cards that Twitter security is built on and it will just tell us that they have been hiding lots of skeletons and nasty secrets that were spun by the company for years.