The main goal of this would be to provide runway outside of the venture capital status quo. Basically a scalable UBI model that doesn't require a huge buy-in by the general public.
As far as who's pulling their weight or not, I believe that framing is a fallacy. Success is stochastic now, meaning that it gets increasingly difficult to predict who will win. That's why VCs invest in 10s or 100s or startups to find a winner that supports the rest, and why all that matters is capital, at least to a first order approximation. This would give us some leverage to start removing the artificial barriers to entry (like how banks generally only loan on assets, not potential) and transition to something more like the Star Trek economy where everything is automated and only machine labor and unearned income is taxed, and the economy is large enough to provide an ever-growing stipend for everyone.
Co-ops exist in industries that require more management than SWE, no reason it couldn’t work for devs too.
Plus, if your first and primary concern is the hard problem of who does more than whom, maybe you just aren’t temperamentally suited for a coop.
Your model could work for businesses that aren't capital intensive (eg. consulting shops), but won't work for anything that requires a runway.
Why would anyone want to invest in a highly risky venture (ie. immature tech companies) with capped upside? It's the same reason why VC companies want equity, not debt obligations in return for their investment.
Interested in responses.
There was an earlier thread with others - I'll try and find it later, maybe.