But is the author the spokesperson for this community to the point that Google should feel compelled to answer him directly?
Google has a lot of resources. They can handle responding to potentially thousands of access requests, especially if they go around publishing glowing results of their own system.
If they wanted to grant access to the scientific community, they'd just launch a closed beta with an official sign-up flow.
I think the author of this blogpost could've had better response contacting paper authors with emails noted on the paper.
Some communities do.
> Granting access "to the community" to investigate scientific claims means making the methodology and results available to everybody - and that includes responding to inquiries for access from anyone (who is worth granting access to.)
Sure, not arguing otherwise.
I'll try to make my point more obvious. If you keep asking questions to different people/orgs and not getting responses there are two possible conclusions:
- Everyone is a jerk or coward.
- You're not as important as you think and not worth the recipient's time.
Unless you work at Google how could you know this?
For example, if it's quadratic, going from 1 000 to 1 000 000 would increase costs by one million fold.