Of course that does not apply to smaller forums and I think that if we had laws that force social companies to not censor people they don't like (let's face it, that's exactly what they want to do), it should be limited to anything that's actually big, not random joe shmoe forum about mushrooms.
This is ridiculous. No one is banned for their opinions on tax policy. No one is banned for their opinions on abortion. People (including the former POTUS) were removed for inciting violence, for fomenting harassment campaigns, and for racism/transphobia/other forms of bigotry.
But it makes sense to me that spreading misinformation about vaccines is a good reason for getting you banned. Vaccines are a matter of life and death not just for people who get vaccinated or not, but to everybody to whom they can spread the disease. If you tell people not to get vaccinated and they believe you, you put their lives in danger.
Similarly you can be prosecuted for shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater causing people to panic and die being trampled and crushed. You could then try to argue that "It is just my opinion that I have the freedom of speech to shout 'Fire' anywhere and whenever I want to". But courts are not going to agree with you.
You are not being banned because of your "opinions" but because of hate-speech. That means speech that can harm others. At least that should be the case, and the law I think.
If they were advertising it as "a website for everyone except these opinions: ...", your point would have been valid. That's why.
Politics aside, Facebook bans people for smallest of things. I got banned for 30 days for quoting someone's comment. It's a censorship dystopia that only people with short-sighted vision of the future could support.
Who wants such an outcome? The haters.
These days, anything and everything that is slightly uncomfortable to groups is labeled as 'hate-speech'. If nobody can define what 'hate speech' really is and if the definition changes person to person, then you're arguing for the wrong reasons. What you're looking for is tightly-isolated communities with consent, bridging and moderation in their own spaces, not worldwide censorship.
I don't like it when others are disrespectful to me, but I always have a choice of shutting down the discussion and moving on. Online communities that spread dangerous ideas are going to form in their own space, no matter what we do so banning any opinions that do not adhere to certain political views is not only dangerous but also creates a division of 'you vs me' and that thing gets ugly quick. If we know 2 communities clash, we keep them separated, as simple as that and it already happens so no big deal. It's like having a work and family chat group, different purposes, different people, different ideas, 0 clashes.
The problem is you're looking at everything through the lens of offensive content. If you tell me that majority of the banned comments on the social media websites are illegal by constitution, you'd have a point but this isn't a reality. People are banned for the smallest of things, for disagreeing with someone else respectfully, for following certain political ideas.
Here's another example: John Stossel was censored even though he posted factual statements - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qmht6Tbtzg
Hate-speech is like pornography. You know it when you see it. Of course one man's "pornography" can be another man's "erotica". But social media companies have the right to decide what they think is pornography vs. what is "erotica", and what they then share or not with all their customers.
Why are we not complaining that Facebook muzzles the free speech of people who want to spread pornography online?
Hate-speech is similar in concept to pornography but far more dangerous. It directly increases the risk of violence.
Should social-media companies be forbidden from blocking pornography on their site?
Your restaurant analogy falls short too. Dress-code is the equivalent of "civility" in discussion, and is a neutral bar that is set. It doesn't favor cotton shirts over linen shirts, which is what censoring a viewpoint would be.
Is hate-speech illegal in USA? What statutes are you thinking of? I thought hate-speech was mostly allowed to exist as "free speech".
The question however is should social media companies not have the right to determine what THEY think is hate-speech, and thus not share it?
If hate-speech is vaguely defined then somebody has to make the decision as to what is or is not it, and whether to spread it online or not. Who better to make that decision than the companies whose business it affects, whether they share hate-speech or don't?
I don't think there's been many cases here involving hate speech. More likely people will pursue defamation and discrimination laws. Many disagree that to be merely "offended" is not enough to establish a crime. Our hate-speech laws are not universally accepted as good laws.
The problem with social media companies deciding what is hate-speech, is they will get it wrong often. The moderator is human. They might be personally associated with a position or viewpoint in their own lives outside of work. They might decide to delete a post that presents a strong case against whatever position they align with, leading to an offended moderator. An offended moderator may not apply the same fairness in all situations. Too many grey areas.