Maybe 10 years ago that as the common things, but there are so many exta resources (esp registers) that is is now giving up almost half the chip. If you can be cache friendly enough, the extra cycles will make up for it.
The only thing that matters at that point is latency, and unless you are cache-friendly enough to store your entire program in a single core's cache twice over, you would be better off disabling SMT altogether. And even if you were able to do that, it would not matter as a single thread would be done processing a message by the time the next one comes in. At least at the currently standard 10-25Gbps that the exchanges can handle.
In HFT, we're fine giving up half the registers in a core if it means we get an extra few microseconds of latency back.