Let me try this again. If you missed that I'm agreeing with you, then others probably did also.
"Modern biological and neurological knowledge" (wording adopted from spicyusername's post) says that our minds evolved over mega-years, to be good enough fast enough to give us a survival edge. They didn't evolve to be pure logic engines, and they show that in all kinds of ways.
Within that view, it is a contradiction to believe "ones own mind being a coherent arbiter of logical reasoning" (your wording). Within the current framework, you can't trust your mind to reach correct conclusions.
I'm not assuming the premise. I'm pointing out that those who do put themselves in a contradictory position.