However, a creative system curated by a human could end up creating useful outputs, could it not?
Something that can be further refined by humans is more interesting. There's people looking into AI-based sample generation which is a lot more promising than full song generation, IMO.
Exactly, that is what I was trying to say. The way I look at it is that most people who have Ableton installed cannot create an amazing song. Now let's say they are able to prompt a Stable Diffusion Audio system with a prompt like kanye type beat with flute melody in the key of E.
The system might output 90% hot garbage, but it's easy to skip that within seconds of hearing it. So they clip and loop the good part, add whatever personal skills they do have, and upload that.
And wow, I just found out that OpenAI's Jukebox[0] was creating this stuff two years ago. This seems like the lowest hanging fruit to me, compared to visuals. Also could be extremely lucrative. I wonder if we are already listen to ML generated music and it's just not advertised?
[0] https://openai.com/blog/jukebox/ related post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23032243
Artists don't always become famous or popular because they're the best, instead it happens because they're pliable in a business sense and fit into a bigger picture of what the product is supposed to be.
I'll give it two years, at most, until we get pretty good audio and video generation from AI.
Have they? If anything, the past few months has shown that after the initial hype dies down, people find the limitations very quickly. It was only weeks ago that people here and on Reddit were proclaiming that graphic designers and artists were no longer needed. But while Stable Diffusion is great at making somewhat surreal images of Jeffrey Epstein eating an apple in the style of Picasso, it's not very good at, say, making a sleek, modern user interface mockup for a bank's login portal. And it turns out graphic designers are currently only paid for one of those things.
You could finetune the Stable Diffusion model to generate UI mockups and would receive much better results.
For some reason, unacceptable uncanny sounds is a much wider valley than unacceptable videos/pictures. The hand holding is uncanny in the family video, but I'm fine watching it for a second - it doesn't cause pain the way that same error would in music.
Eg. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_0JjYUe5jo --> https://vocaroo.com/1hgjjnVNqWjk
We're also working on film generation.