If a prospective spy believes they will be burned by their handling organization, then they will never work for the CIA.
That said your point on trust and incentive doesnt hold up to history. Being an asset and providing information to another country almost always ends in prison, or death, or best case exile. The material rewards are laughably small, thousands of dollars typically. And yet agents, of all nations, are good at their job and consistently succeed in recruiting new assets.
Some become sources for money, others are ideologically prepared to die for the cause and there are even nutcases who are just bored.