> Maybe I have a different understanding of how people use YT…
You’re not disagreeing with my point though. Just talking about it from the other end. But the point you’re making is the same as me: people don’t use YT because a specific content creator is on there. They use it because of the network effect.
> Competitors don't really exist.
Of course they do. There’s literally dozens of big videos sharing platforms. What you’re arguing is that there isn’t any platforms equivalent in size, which is true but that doesn’t mean that there are not competitors on the market.
The problem isn’t a lack of competition, it’s the network effect. It’s the fact that most people watch YT, not $CREATOR who happens to also be on YT.
> Once a large content creator leaves and demonstrates that it's a viable option, other content creators will follow.
YT has already had large (millions of subs) creators leave their platform and it’s had little difference. Hence my point that people are not using YT for specific content creators.
> Having more viewers than subscribers doesn't matter nearly as much as "the algorithm" and how many people get recommended a video.
You’re making a straw man argument here because I wasn’t talking about the algorithm. I was talking about users. I was making the point that subscribers aren’t the full picture in terms of the number of viewers a creator might have.
> People not logged in will not be recommended a flagged video, it will be unprioritized in search results too
You’re making the assumption here that non-subscribed viewers aren’t logged in. That’s usually not the case. Lots of people will be logged in by default (because of GMail et al) but still not subscribing to every creator they enjoy.
Example: I have subscribed to literally zero creators and still see everything you’re claiming I wouldn’t.