I only order pizzza online...that way I can be 100% sure that they actually got my order, and that they'll make it the way I ask for.
Sure if you are only getting a single peperoni pizza you can just call it in, but if you want anything custom or are making a large order, going online is the way to go
For other businesses, I always need to make sure that they a) have good reviews and b) have a decent online presence that shows they are competent