Wrong translation, wrong statement or different laws?
Other than that: Boring.
Wrong translation, wrong statement or different laws?
Other than that: Boring.
If foreign companies want to enter China, they need to obey Chinese law, especially when those laws aren't malicious, make sense, and are enforced correctly, even if the result is ludicrous. Any country should expect the same when a foreign company comes to compete within their shores. And in this particular case, it doesn't seem ludicrous.
Here's a ludicrous example, a close cousin to domain name squatting:
http://www.chinahearsay.com/coca-cola-plays-it-smart-in-its-...
What Apple has going for it here is the fact that it has Foxconn as a key manufacturing partner, which is a huge employer in China. That may give it some political power. Who knows. In the end, $1.6b is chump change for Apple, and it may be worth it for them to just settle.
What Apple has going for it here is the fact that it has
Foxconn as a key manufacturing partner, which is a huge
employer in China. That may give it some political power.
Foxconn is a Taiwanese company. That doesn't count as "political power" in China.So you must also be aware that Foxconn has come under very intense media scrutiny in _China_ since a couple of years ago. Consider this sequence of events:
[1] http://news.softpedia.com/news/Foxconn-Sues-Two-Journalists-...
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Chinese_labour_unrest
[3] http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/07/business/global/07foxconn....
Of course this observation doesn't depend on Foxconn being Taiwanese. But the two are not necessarily unrelated given the increasingly nationalist trajectory of Chinese policy. And more in response to the nature of Foxconn's guanxi with the govt, no amount of it can save Foxconn from uniform wage increases or increasingly negative _Chinese_ media coverage.
http://www.chinahearsay.com/coca-cola-plays-it-smart-in-its-...
It would be more useful if other bottles were included in the comparison. It doesn't matter if two brands of water bottle look alike, if all the other water bottles not pictured also look that way.
That's copyright infringement, plain and simple.
TRADEMARKS: Generally speaking, a trademark is something that signifies or evokes a product provided, sponsored, or endorsed by a particular source. TRADEMARK EXAMPLES: * Word marks such as Apple and iPad; * Logos such as the apple logo; * Sounds such as the "Intel inside" sequence of notes; * Colors, even (sometimes) such as pink for Owens-Corning-brand attic insulation.
(Trademarks are for products; service marks serve the same function for services.)
In a sense, the "owner" of a trademark is really just its government-appointed custodian or guardian. (It's sort of like the old joke: Dogs have masters, cats have staff.) When a trademark owner enforces its rights against an infringer, what the owner is really doing is performing a public service, namely keeping the market free of marks that would be likely to confuse the public.
COPYRIGHT: In contrast, copyright applies to original works of "authorship," regardless whether associated with a product or service.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_in_the_Pe...