Such abstract thinking just doesn't come naturally. We are incredibly biased here because our jobs often require little else except abstract thinking. This is massively atypical.
Such abstract thinking just doesn't come naturally. We are incredibly biased here because our jobs often require little else except abstract thinking. This is massively atypical.
Getting across the concept that the latter terms were - in the context of the source - medical definitions and not going to change with the (ill-defined) average, was difficult at best. There was a lot of "but obviously being overweight means you are above average".
I'm not surprised to see others observing the same issue in different contexts.
Which obviously makes no sense whatsoever: the one person who gets enough food during a famine is not overweight (could be, but that's independent).
Is it really "abstract thinking" to accept an arbitrary "medically-established ideal weight range"? Shouldn't we evaluate the criterion set by the medical community too before we accept it? I hear constant criticism of the BMI system for determining healthy weights, yet I've never really known another standard system.
While I agree that it's bad to compare your chubby kid to the obese kids and write off the weight problem because fatter children exist, I'm not sure how far we should run with the insistence on conformity to numbers like BMIs.
If my children are in the "overweight" BMI range (which isn't applicable to them yet as both are under two) but I still feel that they've been exercising, eating well, etc., and are generally healthy, I'm not going to sweat it.
It's true, not all health conditions are correlated with being overweight. However, a good many of the deadliest health conditions, including heart disease, stroke, cancer, and diabetes are very well correlated with weight. Saying we should discount the effect of weight on health because my weight doesn't predict my susceptibility to car accidents strikes me as misguided.
>To my knowledge, there is no single score or data point that can be used to accurately assess an individual's health.
That's true, but it's also meaningless. There isn't a single score that allows you to predict everything. But, for most people, BMI correlates quite well with the "big-three" medical ailments: heart disease, stroke, cancer. I think that's valuable enough.
http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=CNG.c7aaeb7940626693...
http://www.oregonlive.com/health/index.ssf/2009/06/portland_...
PS: This difference could be social vs physical with more active people taking more risks in their daily lives.
It's not my intention to make such a statement. BMI does have a usage, but it's more nuanced that most people realize and I wished to point that out.
> But, for most people, BMI correlates quite well with the "big-three" medical ailments: heart disease, stroke, cancer.
Do you have any more information or citations for this? It was my understanding that BMI alone was not enough of a predictor for certain ailments and conditions and that usually medical professionals also look at additional risk factors in conjunction with BMI, such as family history or habits like smoking.
BMI boils down to a ratio of weight to height. The fact that this definition doesn't include the word "fat" ought to be a clue that it won't be entirely successful as a measure of a person's fatness. In particular, because muscle tissue is significantly denser than fat. Thus, a couch potato and an athlete, each having the same height and girth, will score such that the couch potato will have a better BMI score than the athlete: BMI penalizes exercise to the extent that it generates muscle mass.
A much more informative measurement would be the body fat percentage. But even this falls down. Apparently there are two kinds of fat. Subcutaneous fat poses little health risk. Internal fat, surrounding the organs, is where the potential problems begin.
The lower half of the "overweight" range is more ambiguous, but statistically speaking the health risks for this range are much less as well (and some studies have determined people in that range to be on average healthier than those in the normal range, perhaps because it includes more physically active people with more muscle). But if your BMI is at a level associated with severe physical health risks (30+ and especially 35+), it's unlikely that muscles are the explanation unless that's obvious.
My numbers: 6'5", 233lb, BMI 27.6 (solidly overweight), squat 180, bench 160, press 120, snatch 90. All numbers are 5 rep work sets except snatch, which is 3 rep work set. ORM might be higher.
The problem is that BMI was designed for sedentary people. It's a good guideline, but it's no substitute for a pinch test.
It is abstract thinking as opposed to concrete thinking, because you are imagining a hypothetical child with a certain build, (or is it a set of children with a range of healthy builds?) and comparing your child to that, as opposed to simply comparing your child to the other children you see in front of you every day when collecting your child from school.
And I don't think there's much of a leap in terms of abstraction if you just jump from "compared to the other kids, my kid is ok" to "compared to this number on a chart, my kid is ok". That is just a change in what data point you prefer to reference, not a change in thought patterns.
However, I suspect you are right and - in actual fact - this may really be what the studies are concluding: that parents of overweight children do not see the problem because the average they see around them is not medically-healthy normal. It would be interesting to see the average weights of children in the study areas to see how much the theory stands.
It would also be interesting to see a similar survey that asked whether they thought their child was within the healthy bounds (i.e. no classifications like "overweight" where they could draw comparisons).