This seems to be at least somewhat weighed against by Yudkowsky's claim to have done it "the hard way", without cheap tricks.
The beauty of the argument is it gives everyone who witnessed the event a very strong motive to lie about it, so it's effectively un-falsifiable. I don't actually think it happened that way, but nothing Eliezer says (apart from that he cheated some other way) would be incompatible with the argument.
Small world, by the way.