I've found that they are receptive of evidence when it comes to efficacy, recidivism, cost, etc. If you care about those things, our prison system makes no sense, it only makes sense if cruelty and maintaining a steady supply of forced labor are the only things they care about.
Criminals generally don't expect to be caught, the quality of prison doesn't matter much if you're not planning on going there.
It's just a business calculation.
if you replace prison time with home arrest, then you remove downside to being caught. Especially for second/Nth time offenders.
In fact you are generally just making your problems worse. First and biggest problem is, that it turns small time crooks into hardcore criminals, because that's the only way to survive on the inside.
So unless you never plan on releasing anyone out of prison, having bad prisons is not great idea.
Second If prisons are so bad, it makes it more likely people will do whatever they can to stay out. There is big difference between spending 2 years doing some manual labor, having bad bed and bad food or being gang raped. And the lesion is not, no to do crime like you and I would hope, but to kill/intimidate witnesses etc.
You have not been around criminals much, and it shows. That’s really not how all of this works, and you’re applying logic to something that offenders themselves often don’t.
If they did, the USAs horrific prison system would work. But it doesn’t.
In 2015 the average robbery netted less than $2,000 while the average sentence length was almost 10 years.
Risking 10 years of your life for $2,000 isn't something that people who understand risk/reward will do, how bad things are while you spend those 10 years is basically a rounding error compared to just how terrible of an idea it already is.
Russia has torture in prisons and 99% conviction rate, how cone their crime rate is high?
Finland's prisons look like 3 star hotels, how come their crime rate is low?