Ammonia as a fuel is quite inefficient due to all the energy conversions. You use renewable electricity to generate hydrogen. You use that to create ammonia. And you then burn that to produce mechanical energy. Each of those steps has poor efficiencies and they multiply. It is way less efficient than using renewable energy to charge a battery that powers an electrical motor. If you start with 10kwh of renewable electricity, you'd be struggling to get more than 1-2kwh delivered in the form of mechanical energy with ammonia. With battery electric it's more like 8kwh. Charging and discharging the battery loses some energy and electrical motors are of course also not 100% efficient.
And when I say inefficient, I mean costly. You waste most of the energy that you put in. It's much more cost effective to use the energy in a more efficient way. By about a factor of 4-5. If you operate any business where energy cost is significant the value proposition of paying 4-5x more is not great.
It's why ammonia as a fuel really barely makes any sense. And hydrogen as a fuel is pretty bad for the same reason. It's a really hard sell when battery electric is a feasible alternative. The economics are flawed. And the second law of thermodynamics means there is no technical fix for this either. There are some hard theoretical limits here.
The way things are trending with PV, efficiency may recede in importance in a couple of decades. Currently electricity costs tens of dollars per MWh. With developments in manufacturing and install protocols, and tech emerging from the lab, and using DC directly from PV panels, that cost may fall to $0.1 per MWh. Using that to manufacture your ammonia means you won't worry so much about pure efficiency
I still prefer methane over ammonia. Much less toxic when things go wrong.
I agree energy will eventually get very cheap and plentiful, which would enable more frivolous uses of excess energy. But still, that won't happen any time soon and the value proposition of paying several times more for energy is very limited. And while there is a shortage of green energy, using it for the creation of fuels seems like it is costly and wasteful.
Electricity isn't free. If you're already wasting sufficient amounts of the requisite elements as waste products of some other thing you're already doing then finding a way to bond those elements and then burn the resultant compound for rotary power may be more economically efficient.
Your sentence is a bit vague, but "some other thing you're already doing" sounds like petroleum refining, which is precisely what we need to do less for use as a fuel. Also, ammonia created from petroleum isn't being wasted today. It's used for making fertilizer, and the whole process has a high cost in CO2 emissions.
When the time comes that we have so much carbon-free energy that we can afford to use the excess to generate ammonia, we ought to use it to displace petroleum based ammonia for fertilizer. There may be a few niches (ocean shipping) that require a liquid fuel like ammonia, but it makes little sense to use it for ground transportation. If a liquid fuel is required, things like sustainable biodiesel make more sense.
That apart, for fast charging or even standard charging you need a reasonably heavily power load from the grid - if you have even 4-5 vehicles charging simultaneously. This would require big changes in the electricity distribution infrastructure.. something which is not required if you continue to use the existing infrastructure used to take fuel to the fuel stations.
Consider that you could easily fully refuel an 18-wheeler in a few minutes time with just a low powered pump.. which is not really possible if the 18-wheeler was a pure EV.
As for the grid, a lot of charging infrastructure relies on batteries and some local production via renewables. That evens out the load on the grid and helps balance things.
Also you have the issue of ships that can’t get electrified yet. Green ammonia might be one way to replace fossil fuels.
In the long run, why not? Between overbuilding renewable capacity (needed for green ammonia anyway), using nuclear when it's cost effective and renewable energy is limited, and multi-day storage, Europe should get pretty close. The last couple percent can be bridged with fossil fuels.
Changing some emissions control equipment, enlarging the fuel tank a little and giving them ammonia when they dock?
Given gas leaks and gas explosions are already a regular thing, pushing hydrogen through the same leaky pipes is not going to improve things.
There's this hydrogen fantasy where people think it's a drop in replacement for methane. The reality is that most hydrogen that is currently produced (from vast amounts of methane typically), is used on site. Transporting it around is just very hard. Even in compressed form, it still takes up a lot of space. Diesel has much better energy density by volume than hydrogen compressed at 300 bar. About 18x for the same volume.