I would also be inclined to ask if you meant to reply to another comment. Let me explain. To me the other option is to say that what you wrote makes no sense and I cannot understand why you wrote it. Asking if you meant to reply to another comment is my way of showing that I don't think you're a crank, but instead you just made a silly mistake any one of us could've. But if I wrote it the other way you might think that I think you're a crank. Y'know?
Anyway my understanding of the original comment is that it was meant as a clarification to the title. Hence why your first reply which starts explaining who Avi Shamir is confused me too.