What would less rights to this look like just curious.
What would less rights to this look like just curious.
What you're suggesting is to do nothing at all, which achieves exactly what is going on right now.
I very often hear a call to end tent encampments.
I very rarely hear any sort of thought out policy on how to end homelessness.
> "Many thousands are in want of common necessaries; hundreds of thousands are "in want of common comforts, sir.”
> “Are there no prisons?” asked Scrooge.
> “Plenty of prisons,” said the gentleman, laying down the pen again.
> “And the Union workhouses?” demanded Scrooge. “Are they still in operation?”
> “They are. Still,” returned the gentleman, “I wish I could say they were not.”
> “The Treadmill and the Poor Law are in full vigour, then?” said Scrooge.
> “Both very busy, sir.”
> “Oh! I was afraid, from what you said at first, that something had occurred to stop them in their useful course,” said Scrooge. “I’m very glad to hear it.”
This is in fact the most commonly adopted practice for “dealing with” homeless people in places like the United States: violently destroying their homes and property at regular intervals, so that they are out of sight and therefore out of mind of people without empathy.
The only way they’re going to stop is if they hit rock bottom. If you’re enabling their behavior that’s never going to happen. And yeah, it’d be rough for them and some will die, but that will cause some others to never go down that road.
You've got it backwards: they're getting high all day because they're homeless and doing what little they can to cope with the insane amounts of stress that entails.
Once you recognize that inverted causality, the solution becomes obvious: provide them with housing and help them back onto their feet.
Yet with your so called obvious solution the problem has gotten worse.
$100 million dollars divided by the approx. 8,000 homeless people in SF¹ (and that's just the ones the city was able to go around counting; I can guarantee that number's far below the actual homeless population) comes out to $12,500 per person. That doesn't cover the year's rent for even so much as a closet in SF, let alone something that even marginally qualifies as a home.
So no, the solution I claim has not been done. Far from it. I'm quite frankly amazed the city could find hotel rooms for that cheap - or, the more likely explanation being that the city is only putting that money toward a fraction of the homeless population.
----
¹: https://sfgov.org/scorecards/safety-net/homeless-population
Seems to me you expect all the working people to just pony up money and pay for all the homeless peoples housing. A lot of people are renting their home and can barely afford to scrape by. They cannot afford to pay for someone else's housing as well. You want to screw these people who are trying to contribute to society. I am not okay with that.
As far as affordable housing, the issue in SF is created and continued by its own residents. They deserve a big part of the blame. If they want to fix it, vote in people that actually allow some damn affordable housing to be built. They all say they want to fix it, as long as its not fixed by putting affordable housing around them.
I think you may be responding to the wrong comment? I never said any of this stuff.
Now this is some proper fucked up high horse shitty cruelty. Its appalling to read it here to keep things polite. It seems you have no clue whatsoever about addictions, how to treat them, what works and what is just some arrogant entitled wishful thinking. I realize similar extreme people are rather outliers, but not so much as we would wish for, hence the topic discussed.
One of those moments when its so darn easy to say 'we have it figured out in Europe in much better and humane way than across the pond'.
I could write an essay about how we have methadone, heroin etc. no-question-asked dispensaries in the middle of one of the richest cities globally, shelters for the poor and actually treat mental illnesses appropriately, but I don't think your type cares about that. Needless to say, we don't have these issues at all while having similar folks as part of society.
People addicted to drugs are only going to stop if they have a reason to. It used to be a mantra: addicts will only stop if they want to and you can't force them.
There are plenty of enabling parents out there that eventually learn this lesson the hard way.
You can either setup incentives pulling those people away from population centers (free food, drugs, shelter) or bring back Mental Hospitals and forcefully incarcerate. What LA/SF seem to be doing now is ... providing free food/drugs/shelter and protection in downtown and wondering why regular citizens complain. Something has to give, the worse it slowly gets the more drastic snap overreaction when things flip and someone radical gets in power.