As for number two, it's hard to comprehend a response that is reasonable because our cognition may be part of the "disturbing reasons" right?
The theory I more and more think is probably right is that there is some major aspect of the universe that we get wrong. What is more likely, humans thinking they understand something when they don't or that no life form was able to spread amongst the stars in billions of years? I have plenty of lived examples of humans with false knowledge.
It's a sort of meta Drake equation. [Likelihood humans are not as wise as they think they are]*[rest of drake equation] and I think the drake equation, as stated, correctly leads to the term "Paradox" given the conventional understanding of science as communicated by scientists.