GDP is like measuring how useful the car is.
So market price tends to be a pretty good proxy for usefulness.
People who complain about GDP as a measure are usually just complaining about things they don’t like that go into GDP like pointless (to them) consumer goods.
> So market price tends to be a pretty good proxy for usefulness.
That's quite a jump; market price can reflect usefulness, but it can reflect a lot of other things too. "This car must be useful to someone because it's expensive" is already questionable logic (at least without stretching "useful" to the point of meaninglessness), and "this car is more expensive than my current car, therefore it would be a good upgrade for me" is blatantly absurd.
Unless you want the government to step in and define appropriate “usefulness” it’s always going to be up to the Buyer.
Exactly. So saying that a more expensive car is always more useful is crazy. Maybe the more expensive car is too big for the roads where I live, or has worse fuel economy, or has less interior space.... Price and usefulness are not completely unrelated, but assuming they're equivalent is absurd.
You aren’t the only buyer, but if they are selling cars someone thinks it’s worth the price.
That’s the beauty of free markets - multiple products for different tastes and different perceptions of value.
I can go out and choose from a small or large, basic or luxury, fuel efficient or not, large capacity or small.
If I don’t think the price is worth the offering, I don’t buy and that impacts the price in some small infinitesimal way. In aggregate across all car buyers manufacturers price for certain segments.
Each product has a subset of buyers who buy the car based on their own interpretation of value.
In a theoretically perfect free market, prices might be equivalent to usefulness. But very few real-world markets achieve that, and the differences are important.
And I don’t buy the predatory advertising idea. People aren’t as stupid as you think and if they’re happy that’s value, if it’s for something you put no value on. I mean hell, Apple is clearly offering “cool in crowd” as value for their products.
And clearly people buy green cars.
Because the rich can pay a huge amount for a marginal increase in usefulness. So you can increase prices more by delivering the same amount of value for the rich than for the non-rich.
> if they’re happy that’s value, if it’s for something you put no value on
And if they're not happy, just numb? An addict will pay to get their fix but it doesn't make them happy, and even they themselves would tell you there's no value or usefulness in it.
> And clearly people buy green cars.
Some people buy cars that are marketed as green, sure. You only have to look at the increasing pedestrian fatality rates in the US to see that there's some kind of market failure going on.
Again, are you saying we should prevent people from using their own money for value you disagree with?
No, unless you're defining value in some very strange way.
> Again, are you saying we should prevent people from using their own money for value you disagree with?
No, I'm saying we should be aware that money and value are not the same thing and our policy decisions should reflect that.