Are you really stating that asking for proof of claims is too much?
How much proof would you be able to find for that? Do you insist an owner speak on the record? "Photographs or it didn't happen"?
So you ask for evidence, and attempt to correlate it.
For the former, some shop owner has to risk his life testifying, or the cops have to have recordings. A newspaper does not and cannot hold to this standard.
That can mean not making judgement based on things which are generally true in cases where it can damage another's reputation or result in the internet mob descending on them.