I'm not sure that's really consensus so much as message delivery, I don't think anyone would notice if posts arrived out of order (for instance). It strikes me as well enough served by a database that gets updates from users on an instance.
So I guess, admittedly I may well not understand, but what does consensus have to do with it?
Mastodon isn't decentralized so I didn't intend to compare them at all. That said, I think federated systems are interesting and have a place, because full decentralization is often impractical.
Daily Active Users and Monthly Active Users, in case anyone else would've had to look it up
The fediverse doesn't have monetization/currency/blockchains floating around so I don't mentally categorize it as web3, but people's definitions certainly vary.
Personally I've signed up four different times and only used Mastodon for a couple months one of those times. Meanwhile I've only ever signed up for Twitter once and I've been posting to it weekly for over a decade. One twitter "new user" and four Mastodon "new users" but the latter didn't retain me.