Anyway it's a cool post! Would be nice to see a follow-up for the upload/sharing part!
Anyway it's a cool post! Would be nice to see a follow-up for the upload/sharing part!
As for your question of "Is that tolerated?" the question is a social one. As the sibling commenter pointed out, if you use a private tracker, you're part of a community that often has a social contract (implicit or explicit) that participation means you need to contribute back and have a good seeding ratio. In that case, only downloading -- like my client does -- is not tolerated and might get you banned. That's why I chose to demo with torrenting a Linux ISO, since those tend to be public, have a lot of seeders anyway, and don't really care how much you upload or download.
There's nothing in the protocol that says you have to do it, and indeed, there are even "selfish" algorithms that try to maximize download speed while uploading nothing in return: https://www.wired.com/2007/01/bittorrent-bullies-bittyrant-a...
And it changes from all those Twitter-related posts recently, to be honest :-).
That code is only downloading, as far as I can tell. Never sharing the file. I was just asking if that's tolerated in BitTorrent. My guess was that it is not.
Well the point of peer to peer is that peers share while they download. Otherwise, if everyone only downloads, then it doesn't really get distributed. Also I meant client/server in opposition to p2p. Many non-p2p systems "on the cloud" spread the load and downtime risk across machines, that is independent from the p2p part.
> using BT to download, but then exiting without attempting to seed anything
I am not saying that you should keep sharing after it is downloaded. But typically BT clients "force" you to share while downloading.
> And the reason I mentioned the "ratio currency" is your use of the word "tolerated" here: BitTorrent isn't the mafia, it's just a protocol that offers the ability to share pieces back to the Internet.
Sure, sorry for my english, not my mothertongue :-). I know it is not the mafia, and I know it is a protocol. I used the word "tolerated" to ask whether or not, in practice, that gets you banned.