Same sort of people also came up with that line of thinking when first making contact with the Japanese: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese-Jewish_common_ancestr...
Some folks just really want to be one of the lost tribes of Israel. Incidentally and unsurprisingly given you know, history, the actual people of Israel do not find this flattering at all.
> As such, I fail to see the relevance of your comment.
By all means, Celts are actually Arabic speakers who have splintered off during the Bronze Age - some 3500 years ago prior to the Kingdoms of Israel and Judea - and the genesis of your theories revolving around the lost tribes of Israel is irrelevant. That bit is just an inexplicable coincidence.
Obvious, my bad for being confused.
Maybe one of us could be enlightened if you look up and provide citations of the author. Surely you'll agree at least that is relevant.
Like the 14th century Declaration of Arbroath (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_Arbroath) pointed out to you by someone else down thread.
Or such charming websites that pepper the web: http://www.israelite.info/thebiblestoryfiles/hebrew-celtic-c...
In 1772, General Charles Vallancey, a leading Irish scholar of the day, published his famous work, "Essay On The Antiquity Of The Irish Language, Being A Collation Of The Irish With The Punic (Hebrew) Language." In his opening remarks he states, "On a collation of the Irish with the Celtic, Punic, Phoenician and Hebrew languages, the strongest affinity, (nay a perfect Identity in very many Words) will appear; it may therefore be deemed a Punic-Celtic compound." Vallancey continues, "from the Hebrew proceeded the Phoenician, from the Phoenician, Carthaginian, or Punic was derived the Aeolian, Dorian and Etruscan, and from these was formed the Latin... Of the Roman Saxon capital letters, the Irish use but three, all the others bear a very great resemblance to the primitive Hebrew and Phoenician."
You say whether or not your theory is derived from these things is somehow irrelevant, my apologies then for possibly mistaking one theory for another, I was not familiar with your version.By all means, cite literally anything, nobody is arguing with you, I'll gladly accept any citation at all.
Whichever heretofore unnamed conjecture he did advance overlaps exactly. I humbly and respectfully accept that it can be some strange coincidence.
It is hypothetically entirely possible that it could be some other theory - one need only cite the author to clear it all up.
All my links are from googling what OP wrote. I respectfully posit the most charitable possible explanation that OP could perhaps be spreading Lost Tribes theories unwittingly.
Why dance around the issue? OP need only lookup whatever he did advance. There is truly nothing to argue about - if it is some other theory I defer to his good judgment as I am not a linguist.
But you are arguing, and you're doing it with incredibly bad tone. Or if you're not, your tone is awful enough that it's hard to distinguish.
One of the best ways to discuss things you have strong opinions about is to do so with a sense of humility and excitement. I suggest you try cultivating that within yourself.
"They journeyed from Greater Scythia by way of the Tyrrhenian Sea and the Pillars of Hercules, and dwelt for a long course of time in Spain among the most savage tribes, but nowhere could they be subdued by any race, however barbarous.
Thence they came, twelve hundred years after the people of Israel crossed the Red Sea, to their home in the west where they still live today."
> They share the same brass work and distinct styles of jewelry.
Are there in your view no other examples of such parallels between different pairs? And if you can find such examples do they all match up towards similar conclusions as what you are pushing here?