To explain, I'll borrow the solution that I first saw in a Fog Creek presentation from ages ago ("DVCS University")...
Essentially, if you have more than one person making changes to the same piece of code, the method for resolving them is:
1) Pull - gets their changes
2) Merge - puts their changes together with yours and you can reorganize them at that point.
Note, this was done with Mercurial which doesn't have the concept of a stage, so Pull feels like it has a slightly different meaning when you look at it that way. One [suggestion][1] for Git if you want to achieve the same effect - getting a Fast-Forward at the end - is to Rebase, then Merge last.
Part of me knew this, I simply forgot and wanted to get out of this particular hole.
[suggestion]: https://www.atlassian.com/git/tutorials/rewriting-history/gi...