In fact I don't buy the “temporary embarrassed millionaire” narrative. I think instead people who disagree with you do so because they truly don't believe in taxes at all or they disagree with a progressive tax system.
I was chatting with a coworker, who is probably the HN type you are describing, about taxes and though we were on different sides of the issue he agreed that taxes were necessary, did not dispute that. He disagreed that it should be progressive however - I think he favored a flat tax rate.
I told him that I saw the collected (collective) taxes as something like a pie (maybe pie chart): the taxes from the poor representing a wedge, the taxes from the middle class another wedge, etc. Slice it up to represent the U.S.'s current (progressive) tax rate — any kind of flat tax or regressive tax is clearly going to mean the rich pay less, the poor and/or middle class pay more.
We can argue as to whether governments collect too much in taxes but to say a flat or regressive tax is "more fair" (to anyone other than the rich) is just a wild notion in my mind.
Myself, I would be an embarrassed billionaire if that were to ever befall me.
The enormous advantage to a flat tax rate is that everyone is in it together. If we have a discussion about whether government should tax more or less, it's hitting or saving all of us (or all of us that earn over the exemption amount anyway). Sure, it hits someone who earns 100x as much 100x harder, but it still hits everyone at least a little bit.
All of this "my plan doesn't raise taxes on anyone earning under $250K or $400K or $1M" is, to me, offensive and divisive. If you want to raise an extra $100K in taxes from someone earning $1.06M, you need to raise an extra $10K in taxes from someone earning $160K (assuming a $60K/yr exemption for a 2 adult household).
I think the opposite. I wouldn’t advocate for a ceiling on wealth, but I would very strongly advocate for a floor.
Nobody should not have a home, food, clothing, education, medical care. But to say someone can’t have a super yacht doesn’t really help the poor.
I'm using „productive“ instead of „work“ for a reason. It's easy find a BS „work“ to do. E.g. I could spend my days bicycling and pretend I'm making a map :) And build some software for fun, e.g. yet another todo app. But neither is productive for the society at large.
I think the answer is partly embedded in your last sentence (“neither is productive for the society at large”).
Let me ask you: if you had all the basics taken care of, what do you think you would do every day for the rest of your life?
Even if I did publish it, I doubt a new app where 10000 already exists helps the society in a meaningful way. Current model, even if with all the flaws, ensures that the market votes what is actually productive or not. Command economy didn't work well. Such hobby-economy probably would be on the same level of inefficiency.
For those who do want, it may become out of reach too. First, taxes are now much higher to build all the housing and everything. Next, it will be harder to find workers if basic needs are there. Both to make money and build the yacht.
Finally, it will be harder to come up with a product. People consume lots of stuff they don't need. They've to work one way or another. Money is there so they spend it. Now if you just had your basic needs met, but didn't have disposable money.. It'd be much bigger step to go find employment to buy random stuff.
What is one person’s run if the mill property is another’s luxury.
For instance, In the discussion you wrote that you’d ride your bicycle and wanna code all day (which requires a computer, and presumably, since you’re on HN participating in thoughtful discussion, an internet connection). There are millions and millions of people who don’t have that, and to them, it is a big luxury item.
A very basic computing device is rather cheap these days. Look at mobile internet penetration in Africa or Asia. Sure, not everybody has it. But it'd certainly make a basic needs list. In worst case - as a shared use devices in libraries. Especially given how modern society relies on digitalisation.
1) Private companies can have a maximum of, say, $1m in revenue per employee before they have to list
2) One individual or entity can own a maximum of, say, 5% of any publicly listed company
So when your company goes well, you have to IPO, and when you IPO, you have to sell most of your shares.
Defining rules like these is far from trivial.
It might stifle the type of megalomania that passes for innovation these days though, and would prevent concentration of wealth that stifles innovation through anti competitive behaviour.
I do mind money being taken from productive capacity and wasted on war, corruption or (ineffectively) on various type of quasi-religious social engineering and propaganda.