This is the surprising one to me. Making Chessbase pay for Stockfish's incurred legal fees not only seems justified but would help deter future infringement of open source licences.
This is the surprising one to me. Making Chessbase pay for Stockfish's incurred legal fees not only seems justified but would help deter future infringement of open source licences.
That often leads a dirty game. Litigation, especially license and IP related litigation, is often all about the meta, the strategy games and ulterior or adjacent motives.
The legal action itself, with associated costs and stresses can be scarier than the judgment. Deterrence or establishing legal cases and such can be the motive. Legal costs can be driven up to strategically raise stakes. Etc. It's nice when occasionally the system can be used to settle disputes or do justice.
Why not? It's not like ChessBase ever contributed anything to StockFish.
> It’s possible ChessBase will sadly lose many customers because of the GPL (though it shouldn’t be so) because some people in our industry and especially companies are allergic to it.
ChessBase sells B2C chess engines, not libraries. Their customer base is either pro-GPL or don't care about it.