I don't think that it really encourages research to create an environment that makes people uncomfortable voicing criticism of those with the greatest power and influence.
I don't think that it really encourages research to create an environment that makes people uncomfortable voicing criticism of those with the greatest power and influence.
Everyone says they want constructive feedback. But most people actively avoid it. If I told you as a young scientist you can go into a field where you will never get praised, just criticized or Vice versa where do you think even most of the top young scientists would go?
No one wants to have their career be “I think I did good work, but pretty much everyone just found issues so it never really made traction”.
Suppose, for instance, that somebody in HCI proposed a new system that would be horribly inaccessible to people with disabilities, to the point that widespread adoption would cause actual harm. Wouldn't it be best for society if the rest of the field felt empowered to criticize their work?
Furthermore, people often feel pressured to praise the works of their friends and colleagues; in doing so, they elevate the most connected members of the field above those doing breakthrough research.