The main question of the quote is: if we introduce a system that rejects a "large" amount of Elixir code, will developers adopt it? If some language features are only available for "untyped" code, will developers often forego types only to get those features? And if that happens, could we end-up "forking" the Elixir community, where part of the community uses some idioms and the other part uses others (which is a common complaint about large languages)?
The goal is not to reject types but rather to find a theory that mirrors the language as close as possible. I believe balancing these trade-offs will be essential to the adoption and success of a type system in Elixir.